Episode 211

How to Start a Country Without Starting a War | Julien Andrew Starr

Published

"You can say the UN is corrupt. It's wrong. It's immoral. It's illegitimate. That's fine. Congratulations. You can say those things. They still exist. There's still 193 members of that club. And it doesn't matter how you feel about it. You want to deal with the world as it is in contemplation of moving the world to the way you want it to be."

Why would a government agree to help you start a competing country?

Negotiating independence means persuading another government to help create a country beside its own. Julien Andrew Starr, Founding Director of the Startup States Society, joins Timothy Allen to explain why he believes that agreement is the most promising starting point.

Timothy begins with Palmer Luckey’s announcement of SLAB, a proposed seasteading project, then turns to the sovereign end of the Free Cities spectrum. What separates an autonomous zone from a country? What would persuade a state to accept a new neighbour? And could a long-term lease align their interests?

Monaco, Próspera, Network School, Liberland and a proposal involving Tuvalu provide different tests of that argument. The discussion follows the distance between an ambitious idea and the agreements, relationships and recognition needed to make it work.

A new country needs a willing neighbour

Timothy describes sovereignty as a spectrum: intentional communities at one end, then different degrees of autonomy, with full independence at the other. Starr compares his objective to training for an Olympic gold medal. Charter cities and special administrative regions offer valuable possibilities, but his particular interest is a new country with national institutions of its own.

That ambition makes the negotiation harder. Timothy asks why a government would agree to create a potential competitor. Starr’s response is that openly stating the objective also removes ambiguity. A government knows what is being proposed, rather than wondering whether a project seeking limited autonomy has a longer-term plan for independence.

What Monaco gives France

Monaco makes the discussion concrete. It is independent, yet reaching it usually involves passing through French territory. Visitors spend money in nearby towns, use transport infrastructure and contribute to the wider Riviera economy. Its relationship with France combines sovereignty with practical interdependence.

For Starr, the lesson is to be a good neighbour. A new jurisdiction needs to understand the interests and sensitivities of the people around it. Timothy also raises the less comfortable consequence of Monaco’s appeal: demand for its limited supply of property puts residence beyond the reach of many people.

Execution matters more than declarations

Próspera and Network School show two different ways of working with existing states. Timothy sees Network School’s move from Malaysia to Kazakhstan as evidence that an organised community can have bargaining power. Starr focuses on execution: both initiatives have secured arrangements that let them operate.

But autonomy has limits. Customs, immigration and the surrounding national government can remain important constraints. Starr’s preferred approach starts with discussing the possibility of statehood itself, while recognising that Próspera and Network School are pursuing their own objectives.

Why claiming land is the difficult route

Liberland brings recognition into focus. Timothy describes independence as a more binary proposition than a negotiated degree of autonomy: neighbouring countries either accept the claim or they do not. Starr discusses contested territory, effective control and the problems attached to supposedly unclaimed land.

He is supportive of seasteading, but sees additional legal obstacles to declaring an independent country at sea. His preference is to avoid territorial disputes and begin with an existing state that is willing and legally able to negotiate. He also argues for stable institutions: a friendly politician is not enough if a change of government can undo the arrangement.

A lease instead of a purchase

Starr points to Steve Clancy and Eleutheria’s New Nation Project, whose proposal involves land reclamation and a sovereign lease in Tuvalu. Timothy challenges the example’s wider relevance. Reclaiming land lost to rising seas is a specific problem, rather than a business case that can simply be repeated everywhere.

Starr broadens the argument to land that has little present economic use and is expensive for its existing government to administer. Under his proposed model, the existing state would retain ownership while negotiating the terms of a long-term lease and a new jurisdiction. Rent, royalties or commercial interests could give it a continuing stake in the project.

The Tuvalu discussion concerns a proposal and negotiations, rather than an established independent country. The distinction matters to the model: creating valuable development, negotiating a sovereign arrangement and gaining wider recognition are separate achievements.

Permission, recognition and powerful friends

Timothy’s survey of recent country formation leads to Montenegro and Kosovo. Starr uses their different experiences to illustrate the importance of agreement from the state a territory is leaving. Recognition by individual countries, treaty relationships and membership of the United Nations are related questions, but they are not interchangeable.

Bougainville, Greenland and a historical example involving Katanga widen the discussion. Even a promising agreement with one government can encounter opposition from a larger power. Starr argues that a prospective country needs relationships beyond its immediate neighbour and a clear explanation of the problems it can help solve.

After decolonisation

Will the next wave of countries emerge through the fragmentation of large states, or through new agreements? Starr does not expect the imminent breakup of the United States or other major powers. He sees economic incentives as a substantial part of both separatist movements and the arrangements that keep countries together.

The Startup States Society’s focus is different: helping people investigate peaceful, ethical and lawful new-country formation. Starr rejects displacement and covertly encouraging secession. The closing discussion covers the small number of visible initiatives, his five monographs and two atlases, and Timothy’s question about the relationship between Olivier Janssens’ earlier Free Society project and Destiny in Nevis.

Explore the research

Supporting the show

Lead show sponsor Veritas Villages develops freedom-oriented communities in Panama, Costa Rica and Nicaragua. The show is also supported by AmityAge whose work turns stranded gas into power for Bitcoin mining in Alberta. Explore the project. Join the newsletter for new conversations and updates.

Enjoy the conversation.

Audio version

Includes Timothy Allen’s introduction and additional commentary not included in the video.

211 - How to Start a Country Without Starting a War | Julien Andrew Starr

Follow Timothy Allen on YouTube

Subscribe for upcoming films and conversations about the people building freer societies.

Subscribe on YouTube

In this episode

  • Negotiating new sovereign countries with existing states
  • Monaco and the relationship between a small country and its neighbour
  • Próspera, Network School and the limits of autonomy
  • Liberland, territorial disputes and recognition
  • Eleutheria’s proposal involving Tuvalu and reclaimed land
  • Long-term sovereign leases, rent, royalties and commercial incentives
  • Montenegro, Kosovo and agreement from the parent state
  • The influence of larger powers on new-country formation
  • Decolonisation, separatism and the durability of large states
  • The Startup States Society, monographs and atlases
Read transcript

Julien Andrew Starr: I want to upload a separate video version Leave unchecked to just provide audio Ad-free I want to upload an ad-free version Scheduling Schedule release date Early access Transcript Review auto-generated transcript

Timothy Allen: I don't know whether you saw on the news today. Do you know who Palmer Luckey is? Do you know that guy?

Julien Andrew Starr: I do not know. Who is he?

Timothy Allen: He's a he's a he's a he's the guy that invented the Oculus and he's just he's just one of those he's a kind of interesting character a bit of a Peter Thiel type character. Okay, but I think more likable actually a lot of people [unclear]. Anyway, this morning he actually he mentioned on twitter that he's he's been working on this project called SLAB for a long time which is a ginormous floating city.

Timothy Allen: And he's he's one of those guys who's who's pretty genuine you know in the seasteading world you hear you hear a lot of talk of people you know coming up with plans to do xyz this that and the other and as far as I can tell there's only about three or four projects which are serious and none of them are on that grand scale. But it looks like he is and he's really kind of, you know, going for it. So I think that's amazing news.

Timothy Allen: I think there's a lot of news coming through about about the very sovereign end of things I think and that I think that's where I'd like to start actually because we had a brief chat the other day, right? And I'd quite like your take on on on the completely self-sovereign end of the of the Free City spectrum. Just for listeners I'd sum it up I like to think of it I like to think of sovereignty as a spectrum.

Timothy Allen: At one end you have intentional communities and then you go through the different levels of independence until you make it to the very far end, which is places unashamedly looking for complete independence from the state. Right. And, and it's the, it's the most, how can I put it? It's the least active and most dangerous end of the spectrum, I would say, because it's very difficult to realize the result that you're looking for. First of all, is that a decent way of, of explaining it? Do you think?

Julien Andrew Starr: I'm comfortable with it. I'm completely comfortable with it. Sometimes I look at it as karate, right? There's different belts. You have your yellow belt, you have your white belt, you have your green, your red, and you ultimately have your black belt, if you will. But I think of it in slightly different terms. I think of it more along the lines of training for the Olympics. And this is something also that a buddy of mine who does serve on the advisory council for the Startup States Society also likes to make reference to. It.

Julien Andrew Starr: He's training for the gold medal. I'm training for the gold medal and the gold medal being a fully independent new country. Right. And then different gradients below that would be perhaps a special administrative region, a charter city and different degrees, different variations below. I do concede that it could potentially be the most dangerous, but I also think it could be the least dangerous because there's no Trojan horse problem. Well, you're just secretly trying to do this or that. Your charter city today will try to achieve independence tomorrow.

Julien Andrew Starr: Here, there's no concern like that because right out of the gate, independence is on the table, which does make it demonstrably harder and more challenging to be sure but it also doesn't have the same hidden agenda issue that I think unfortunately does plague a lot of people in the subnational industry and unfairly so and unfairly so that's interesting because I would

Timothy Allen: Have said that find that going to a government and saying now here's a plan to create a zone a small zone which will benefit you yes in the long run and the short run versus going to that same government and saying I'd like to create a border with you that does seem like a lot of a harder ask but you go go a little bit more deeper into why you think it's it's that it's not as bad

Julien Andrew Starr: As I make it sound. No, you're so right. You're 100% correct. And it's these types of objections are normal. They're natural. In many instances, they're correct. So then one of the workarounds, if you will, is that there would necessarily not be a hard border, right? So the classic example would be France and Monaco. We'll probably go back to that example often. And there isn't really a hard border.

Julien Andrew Starr: If you're driving in one part of France or you're on a bus or a train, sometimes you don't even realize it, but you've entered Monaco, you've left Monaco, you've reentered France. So there are different ways of configuring this. That doesn't have to be, for example, the U.S.-Mexico border. It doesn't have to be an arrangement like that. And I think in all likelihood, it wouldn't be. And other factors that could be introduced into the equation could include in the case of we would like to rezone this area as a new country.

Julien Andrew Starr: Your citizens still have free access to the area, right? So then they're not losing access. Perhaps they're getting priority for employment. Perhaps certain industries might even be allocated simply for citizens of the host country, of the landlord or transferring state. So this is where the wheeling and dealing, this is where, and I know this is perhaps That's not the correct term to use, but the art of the deal comes into play real fast.

Timothy Allen: What can you tell me about the history of how Monaco started then and whether or not that's the kind of sovereign place we could see in the 21st century?

Julien Andrew Starr: Right. So their history goes back several centuries. Centuries, the Grimaldi family, and they once had a much larger territory, and they've been able to maneuver between different powers, right? So there would be the House of Savoie, there would be the different Italian kingdoms, and certainly the French kingdoms and empires, and trying to simply play them off against each other, although they did have to concede a tremendous amount of territory. They, as far as I understood, went all the way up to Menton and they had lots of different towns and villages.

Julien Andrew Starr: But in order to have their area recognized, they had to take a bit of a hit. And to be fair, and this is a natural pushback to all of this, hey, let's start a new country business, is that unfortunately, you're right away going to have to work in the world of navigating against big powers and between them and learning how to survive. And it's a difficult situation, but I would imagine in the corporate world, it's no different. You want to go up against Amazon or NVIDIA.

Julien Andrew Starr: You have to deal with the reality that they have a lot of the plumbing and infrastructure out there on the web that you're going to have to deal with, or the hardware in the case of an NVIDIA. So there's that. As far as the more contemporary history of Monaco, I believe it was in 62 or 63, there was a treaty that was concluded involving the then president Charles de Gaulle of France and Monaco, where certain other concessions Monaco had to make.

Julien Andrew Starr: So if you're a French citizen, you don't get to benefit from the lack of income tax that the principality has. And so it was a convention that they came to that would codify and recognize the existence and independence of Monaco while still placating the authorities in Paris. And I think it was only, I don't remember offhand, maybe the late 90s or early 2000s that Monaco joined the United Nations. So many of these European microstates didn't even make it to the UN until relatively recently.

Julien Andrew Starr: Andorra, 93, Switzerland, I think it was 2002, although they're not a microstate. So there has always been that concern about supranational powers and supranational and international bodies that I think many of these smaller countries have had and mightfully so.

Timothy Allen: What do you know much about how France currently views Monaco, whether it feels like it's a bit of a thorn in their side or whether they think it's a sort of net benefit? You know.

Julien Andrew Starr: Well, I suppose it depends on who you're speaking with. So the tourism authorities on the Riviera in the Provence-Alpes-Maritimes region love Monaco because Monaco is a major draw. So people that are going to visit the principality are going to also spend time in neighboring communities, Villefranche-sur-Mer, [unclear place name]. And they're going to be spending money all around. In order to access Monaco, you're going to most likely fly into Nice to take the train in through other parts of France's territory.

Julien Andrew Starr: And in many respects, that's also a model that new countries could seek to emulate is, well, it's the rising tide situation. So in order to reach this new country, they're probably going to be going through your territory in part as one option and spending money there as well. So there is that too, but it also poses a vulnerability as well, right? So you could have a situation where you have perhaps, and this is a dramatic visual, but a Berlin-style airblock, right?

Julien Andrew Starr: When the Soviet Union tried to cut off Berlin from the rest of what would have been East Germany at the time and the rest of Germany, making it difficult for supplies to get in. So you have that problem as well, to be fair about it. I don't envision anything like that ever occurring where France were to do that to Monaco. Definitely those on the French left love to bash Monaco as this tax haven. Meanwhile, they probably have workarounds where they're able to do things there themselves.

Julien Andrew Starr: Even though French citizens don't have any sort of fiscal benefit to doing anything in Monaco, I'm sure they have workarounds. And the reason I know that beyond just speculation is because every time they bash Switzerland, we find out this minister has an account there or that minister has an account there. And so it wouldn't surprise me. Usually that's the case, right? It's the cliché of the 80s televangelist preacher you know decrying adultery And then we find out years later he perhaps wasn't so faithful to his wife

Timothy Allen: I know it's not a fashionable thing to say but I tend to agree with you there I always thought that the existence of independent states like Monaco will always continue in perpetuity for that exact reason. And that is that there will always be a requirement for places where, for example, people don't pay tax, there will always be that requirement.

Timothy Allen: And currently, when you see the sort of evolution of somewhere like Monaco from my perspective at least it's evolved to be a place that only wealthy people can live and that wasn't even necessarily by design that was that was the market which showed us. That if you want a free a tax-free lifestyle you need to live in Monaco you need to buy somewhere to live in Monaco and as a result lots of wealthy people want to live there want to buy there and the price of property is just astronomical as far as I know.

Timothy Allen: So I think probably going forward in the future that will always exist I'm not sure that's necessarily a good way to market those kind of places because I mean when we look at say Monaco then do we see some of the benefits of an independent place like Monaco, sort of reaching out into the wider community around there or not? Because that would be probably where Free Cities folk would say, well, look, here's why it's a good thing.

Julien Andrew Starr: Right. No, they most certainly do. They do a lot of outreach beyond their borders. And not just because they feel that they want to put their name on buses or stadiums or any of that, but because they're in the neighborhood. So it's a matter of being a good neighbor. And this is something that many of these types of efforts at even the subnational level ought to take a page from. You got to be a good neighbor.

Julien Andrew Starr: And you also do have to deal with that human condition known as envy and to deal with it and to be sensitive to it.

Julien Andrew Starr: Okay there's nothing wrong with being a good capitalist but you also want to stay you want to stay in existence you want to stay in business it also makes sense to take into consideration the very real human dimension of these things one of the other geniuses of some of these smaller countries is they sometimes get a chance to do certain things that larger powers may not necessarily want to put their name on. So just a very quick example that's also in the news. We see movement.

Julien Andrew Starr: I know they're not exactly a European microstate, but El Salvador and Central America and their efforts in Haiti. I don't think it's a stretch of the imagination that U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio is doing a little more than giving them a nod and a wink. So it may not be palatable for the United States, which has Iran and Ukraine on its hands, to have a front in Haiti. So they'll let a third party, such as El Salvador, that has a casus belli, a pretext, to go in there.

Julien Andrew Starr: And this is where smaller powers can rise to the occasion. Not that I'm necessarily advocating setting up a country to do the dirty work that the larger powers don't want to co-sign publicly, although there is that dimension too. And that's something to be very much aware of when we start to get into these geopolitical type discussions.

Timothy Allen: Interestingly, so far, we've only mentioned small places, relatively small places. Do you think there's a size limit to this kind of science, the science of creating new states?

Julien Andrew Starr: Yeah, I hope not. I hope that there's a tremendous amount of scalability. The concern always is as you grow and as you scale, you take a hit on quality and the personal rapport. Or it's the problem of the firm as the mom and pop shop or your favorite restaurant that then opens up two or three other locations. And it's difficult to maintain that level of intimate rapport. I know as far as the issue of scalability, there is the, I don't want to say elephant in the room, but there almost is of the network state phenomenon.

Julien Andrew Starr: Right. So now as popularized by Balaji Srinivasan, the ex-CTO of Coinbase, as I understand it, his idea runs a little bit like this in terms of size and limitation. And I hope I'm not mischaracterizing it. I'm not as intimately familiar with his doings as people think, but it goes sort of like this. So there was Greece, and Greece begat Rome, and Rome sort of begat Britain, and Britain begat the United States.

Julien Andrew Starr: And then his conclusion is, and the United States begat the Internet, as if the Internet is some sort of a polity or empire onto itself. And presumably what he means by the Internet is the network state or network states. And so I suspect that's the direction that he sees things as far as the direction that I see things as far as a terrestrial new country on land, analog, right, as opposed to digital. There are probably practical limitations.

Julien Andrew Starr: Let's face it, I don't know just how much land anyone can negotiate to lease or to purchase in order to starting a new country. So there are probably those limitations, those very practical limitations. But as far as being able to scale it digitally, probably not.

Timothy Allen: Yeah, obviously. I don't know. I was a lot more skeptical of the network state a couple of years ago, has to be said. And mainly because of my experience with the tech world in general. And in the case, and in as much as they're the kind of move fast and break things people. So they don't mind if they create a thousand companies as long as one of them is really successful, which isn't necessarily the way my brain works. So I'm not saying it's right or wrong.

Timothy Allen: And my major issue previously with the network state was that the barrier to entry to a network state is so low that I don't really read those signals very well if you've got a hundred thousand people signed up to your network state that how many you know it's like watching youtube how many people watch your youtube video or a million and then you look at the stats and it's like most of them watch the first five seconds.

Timothy Allen: You know it's like so but we've seen some interesting sort of changes in the network state recently most notably the fact that they occupied some sort of abandoned buildings in Malaysia and then the malaysian had a bit of a tiff with the malaysian government over whatever. I'm not quite 100 sure I never quite got to the bottom of it but they got kicked out of the country and another country instantly put their hands up Kazakhstan and said we'll have you. Now as far as I'm concerned that's a proof of concept.

Timothy Allen: Because the whole point of the network state concept is you have this bargaining power of your 100,000 signups saying to a country, hey, let us come to your country because we're going to bring all this with you. And it appears to have happened. You know, they're now in Astana, in Kazakhstan, at this amazing tech center, and the Network School is carrying on as per normal. And potentially, I don't know whether this is true, Malaysia are probably thinking, oh dear, we've just lost a pretty good customer there.

Timothy Allen: So yeah, I'm definitely more on board with the network state idea because there's now some physical manifestations proving the model, just like in a way Próspera is proving the model. It's going up against its government, or let's say the previous government who didn't like them, and it appears to have survived. And because this whole space has been rejuvenated in the last few years, we're basically running through all the examples again, I think.

Timothy Allen: We can sure look back to history and say, oh, yeah, this network, this state flourished, this city state was amazing, this, that and the other. But really, none of them have come head on collision with the 21st century until now. And that's what we're seeing.

Julien Andrew Starr: No, I'm with you. I'm wildly in favor of Próspera personally and wildly in favor of the Network School and the network state movement. I love them both. I think they're both extraordinarily successful. And the reason I say that is because you look at Próspera, for example, they have a deal. I mean, what else do I need to say? They scored a deal. They won. You look at the Network School, you're right.

Julien Andrew Starr: They had a situation, I believe it was the forest, the old forest city, special zone in Johor State, Malaysia, right on the line with Singapore. And now they have some sort of an MOU with Kazakhstan. Fantastic. And that's great. It is possible that the Network School was scouting for additional locations before the situation with Malaysia unfolded. It's also possible that they may have gotten wind, that there was some sort of a situation with the Malaysian authorities.

Julien Andrew Starr: And so, yeah, I mean, look, I'm supportive of those that get deals because ultimately, perhaps it's cliche to say, but execution is everything. And so, or almost everything. And So I'm very supportive of these things. And I remain so. But then I also look at them and I say, okay, you take an example of Próspera. What are some of the vulnerabilities that Próspera has through no fault of their own? And one of them is clearly they've had immigration and customs issues. They haven't exactly had control over their own immigration and customs.

Julien Andrew Starr: And this has been among the myriad of different issues that they've faced, again, through no fault of their own. And so how then to address those? And this is, again, where the pursuit of starting new countries, I think, very much comes in, is that right out of the gate, for the most part, you likely will have control over your own immigration and customs. Or many people would probably say we won't even have customs. We'll go the way of Hong Kong and be a relatively duty-free area. And that's perfectly fine.

Julien Andrew Starr: That's up to each individual country founder to make those determinations for themselves. And that's where the Startup States Society does take a bit of an agnostic, viewpoint-neutral position where, okay, different founders of different countries can have their own different flavors. If they want to experiment and go in one direction, that's perfectly fine versus another direction. But you look at Próspera, they are a great case in point of what is and what can be, but why not go a little bit further?

Julien Andrew Starr: I understand they never had, to my knowledge, any sort of designs on being a separate country vis-à-vis Honduras, and that's perfectly fine. At the same time, why not go just a little bit further? And that's where I fall into that column, so to speak.

Timothy Allen: I was looking through your publications and monographs and stuff yeah and obviously a core part of your thesis is the deal as far as I can tell. Yes can you can you elaborate on that a bit and probably what I'm very interested to know is how do you get that deal I mean you've just spoke about Próspera right and I agree and Próspera are not necessarily have ever said, as far as I know, that they're looking for any kind of sovereignty beyond what they already have.

Timothy Allen: And I think probably there's a really good reason for that as well. Because when you leave the area of the spectrum on which Próspera lies and move a little bit further, you basically hit Liberland very, very quickly. And Liberland is basically a zero or one thing, as far as I'm concerned. Whereas Próspera is a little bit more like, yeah, the edges are a little bit greyer and therefore easier to manage, potentially easier to negotiate. Whereas someone like Liberland has the issue of you're either Liberland or you're not.

Timothy Allen: And in order to be Liberland, like it or not, you kind of need other countries to acknowledge that fact. And if the people on your border aren't acknowledging it well you have a problem

Julien Andrew Starr: Yeah no you really do and so as far as getting that deal okay to back up just for a moment I am I don't know this for sure but if I had to if I were into gambling and I wanted to put 100 euros on it I would imagine it has definitely crossed the mind of people that are linked to Próspera that, hey, maybe we ought to start a country too. I'm sure many, many people in the Free Cities world, many people in the Charter Cities world, many people in seasteading have had this thought.

Julien Andrew Starr: I'm almost positive they have. I'm positive if you scratch the surface a little bit, you're not going to find too many people that would say, no, no, please, I don't want it. I don't want it. I don't want it. No, please. Although some might say, no, I don't want it because I don't want the burden and the responsibility of statehood. That's the other side of the coin, too, that very few people do talk about.

Julien Andrew Starr: There is a myriad of different international conventions that, in many cases, as a new country, you're going to want to be a part of in order to gain acceptance into the broader international community. But okay, right. So then why? Why is it that so many, I think, stop at the water's edge and don't go and cross the Red Sea, so to speak, to that promised land, right? Maybe that's a terrible analogy given contemporary history. In fact, it's a terrible analogy perhaps given contemporary history. But what can I say? Well, it is what it is.

Julien Andrew Starr: And I think the reason for that is because there hasn't been anyone that has truly taken it so seriously, the idea of deliberately designing intentional new countries. That's one thing. There hasn't really been as much of that kind of an effort. Sure, there was the Free Society people that I'm sure we'll have to talk about at some point. And there is that. And there have been other cases in the 70s and the 80s with the Phoenix Foundation. So there's that.

Julien Andrew Starr: And I do very much write about those examples in the different monographs, particularly the eponymous one, Startup States. So, OK, how do you get a deal? Right. How do you get a deal? Well, I'll give you one clear example that's ongoing, because maybe that's the best way of doing this. And first of all, you have to ask real nice. I mean, you really do. So that means, and this is really important.

Julien Andrew Starr: I know this is going to sound, it sounds almost juvenile, but a lot of these notions of the envelopes full of cash, the box of cigars, the sponsoring coup d'etats. I'm looking at you, Margaret Thatcher's son, allegedly, reportedly, right? Mark Thatcher in escapades in Equatorial Guinea, about 20 odd years ago. So those are bad ideas, ladies and gentlemen. Don't touch them. Don't think about them. Don't get involved with it. Those are all the really wrong ways of doing these types of things. And so then, okay, now we're going back to Liberland.

Julien Andrew Starr: And whether Liberland has a legitimate claim to the Gornja Siga area or not along the Danube, that's a whole other story. I write about that extensively. There are cases in both directions. There are cases people can look up, the Island of Palmas case, the East Greenland case. These are old pre-World War II international cases that deal with matters of effectivités and effective control over territory.

Julien Andrew Starr: And so it's very problematic that the Croatian police have been patrolling the Gornja Siga area, not just for the practical reasons, but there are very real legal implications at public international law that unfortunately don't bode well for Liberland. Okay, so what am I getting at with this? The problem with the Liberland is they have all these headwinds, right? Let's assume that their claim is completely lawful. And it may be, it probably is, it could be. It also might not be. Okay, in the Startup States Society, some are more pro-Liberland than others.

Julien Andrew Starr: But okay, so you have all this headwind. I think that's, in my opinion, no offense to them, that's the first mistake. Don't do anything where you, out of the gate, have these headwinds So claiming a morsel of Marie Byrd Land in West Antarctica Bad idea Why? Because you have the 1959 Antarctic Treaty that kicks in So any signatory to that convention is probably not going to recognize you Seasteading Love it Highly supportive of it Big time fan of Joe Quirk, huge fan of [unclear name], huge fan of Mason [unclear surname] and Atlas Island.

Julien Andrew Starr: I think they're a thousand percent great. I have no problem with them. The concern is there is the law of the sea and unquote. Right. So maybe you are working with an existing country to use their flag and then you hoist their own flag that could potentially work. But then you're going to have the signatories to those conventions that are that may or may not be comfortable with you trying to say, well, this is a separate country in the high seas. That's a big problem.

Julien Andrew Starr: There are lots of issues at public international law that effectively foreclose on that as well. So then we go back to the Liberland, we go to the Bir Tawil between Egypt and Sudan. And so there's been no shortage of people over the years that have claimed these areas of so-called terra nullius or no man's land. Maybe they're terra nullius, Maybe they're not. There was a 1975 case, the Western Sahara advisory opinion that came out, which effectively dispelled the concept of terra nullius. This was something that Morocco claimed.

Julien Andrew Starr: Well, you know, there are no people living in Western Sahara. It was just a Spanish colony. These Sahrawi people, they don't really count. Well, there's been cases, there's been lots of cases adjudicated before different international bodies that dispel this notion that there really is terra nullius. You could say, well, that was 75. The Liberland situation emerged much after. That was an advisory opinion. It wasn't so binding. And the dissolution of Yugoslavia came up much after that 1975 decision. Okay, fine. So, but you see all of this back and forth.

Julien Andrew Starr: These are headwinds that you want to avoid. So, my approach, my attitude And that of the Startup States Society is: let's not even get involved with any of that, because that's a lot of lawyering. That's a lot of back and forth. It's not to say we don't have super talented lawyers On the advisory council of the Startup States Society. We most certainly do. Some real legends, to put it mildly. But why trip over that wire? So then, okay, how do you get a deal? How do you get a deal?

Julien Andrew Starr: First, you're going to want to work with an existing United Nations member state because right now in November of 2026 they are the body of record they are the club of nations. You can say the UN is corrupt. It's wrong. It's immoral. It's illegitimate. That's fine. Congratulations. You can say those things. They still exist. There's still 193 members of that club. And it doesn't matter how you feel about it. You want to deal with the world as it is in contemplation of moving the world to the way you want it to be.

Julien Andrew Starr: OK, and so you got one hundred and ninety three and you're going to likely want to start negotiating with countries directly that are not so desperate for a deal because that could be dangerous, but that are not the maybe not in need of a deal. Right. So this is a terrible analogy, but you don't necessarily want to ask the girl to dance that nobody, you know, nobody's asking to dance. But you also don't want to necessarily ask the girl that everybody's asking to the dance. Right.

Julien Andrew Starr: So you want to find that sort of sweet spot, if you will. Someone more likely to say yes, as opposed to, no, I've had 17 offers already, or someone that has maybe a substance abuse problem that you should really stay away from. I'm not totally kidding here. So you want to find that.

Julien Andrew Starr: This is one of the problems that so many people in the subnational jurisdiction industry, as I refer to it, fall into is sometimes they end up doing deals with countries that are perhaps not so lowercase d democratic, that maybe have less than clean, clear legal infrastructures in place. And then your friend today gets deposed tomorrow, your deal is kaput. That's a problem. So, all right, so let me answer the question directly. So one of the gentlemen who I've mentioned before, Steve, Steve Clancy, newnationproject.org, Eleutheria, he's in active negotiations with the South Pacific country of Tuvalu.

Julien Andrew Starr: And for those that perhaps are not so familiar, the .TV domain name is their big source of revenue because the name of the country is Tuvalu and they have .TV. And again, whether or not climate change is real or it's man-made or it's just a hoax, doesn't really matter We can have those discussions in a Telegram group, a Discord server, that's perfectly fine But Tuvalu really is sinking, they are Steve flew out there, they're sinking, they're losing land to a rising tide It just is and who's to blame for that? Again.

Julien Andrew Starr: I let scientists debate that I sure many of us have our own ideas on the matter So his idea is to help them reclaim some of their territory And then he's going to lease back some of that land that he helps them to reclaim, much as Singapore has been able to reclaim some land, the Netherlands have been able to reclaim some land. And then he's going to lease it back in the form of a new country. And thus far, there have been no objections from the highest levels of the government of Tuvalu.

Julien Andrew Starr: And so that's one public conspicuous example that I can share where you need to identify what is it they need? What is it they want? Are they at risk for climate change? Do they need employment? Do they need investment? Do they need a good neighbor? You know, some countries just want to have friends. I know this sounds really strange, but a lot of times countries want to have friends or it can also be presented from another positive metaphor of having children. Right. The UK has had a lot of children.

Julien Andrew Starr: I mean, it's the granddaddy of so many different countries. And maybe it's not the best analogy either. But when you pitch it in terms of birthing new countries, midwifing new countries, the concept of life and creation, these are things that are receptive to different decision makers in many countries in the world because they have families and they understand that. And it's a lot better than just pitching it as, well, we're going to build the next Hong Kong. Well, yeah, you know, that just doesn't really work.

Julien Andrew Starr: OK, it doesn't work for a myriad of reasons, not least of which the analogy is a rather scary one, because let's not forget that Hong Kong came about through the opium wars and the humiliation of China. And that's something that is not lost on people in the global South. I'm not necessarily saying that I'm a fan of everything that comes along ideologically linked to the global South and breaks and things of that nature. It's just that it is a reality, too. So those Hong Kong analogies are not always great.

Julien Andrew Starr: I understand what people in the Free Cities world and the subnational jurisdiction world mean. They mean an area where there's positive non-intervention in terms of economics. They don't mean they want to recreate the opium war or the treaties of humiliation vis-à-vis China. I understand that. So you want to ask nicely. You want to identify needs, right, just like in any sort of business type of situation.

Julien Andrew Starr: And this is very much why it's the Startup States Society and Startup States is applying that startup mentality to statecraft and coming up with those more out-of-the-box type approaches to public international relations.

Timothy Allen: Wow something that just occurred to me when you were speaking then was that your Tuvalu example which is a phenomenally interesting one is is is I'm assuming what you were describing where you were aiming at this sort of place that's going to be that's you know that's right for your project.

Timothy Allen: However, that's such a specific use case it makes me think because on the whole people in our movement like the idea of the reason we should create this is because there's going to be an effect and an advantage to the host nation and it's normally an economic one on the whole. And I suppose there's an element of that in your Tuvalu example but really I feel a little bit disappointed that the best example we've got is one which has such a specific use case, which is reclaiming land lost to the sea.

Timothy Allen: Do you think that the idea that approaching a government and saying, look, I want to create this new place and it's going to be really beneficial to you, do you think it doesn't have enough legs? Because they look at that and they go, well, kind of, yes, but you're also basically going to become my competitor pretty soon.

Julien Andrew Starr: Right. Well, this is where pitching it more as a joint venture. So perhaps another example, this is a hypothetical speculative example is where you have one of these UN member states that happens to have idle territory, non-performing territory. Maybe it's remote, which does, by the way, then the logistical considerations kick in. It becomes a lot more challenging and difficult. So what Steve is going to be trying to do in Tuvalu is going to be difficult. It's remote. It's far. It's not near other major population centers. And I do understand this.

Julien Andrew Starr: To be clear, that's very much his initiative, not mine, although I'm wholly supportive of it. And he is an advisor at the Startup States Society. What it is, is this. So you have a country, let's say, that has remote territory, idle territory. Maybe they still need to administer it, patrol it, what have you. And it's a net loss for them. So the idea here is you're approaching a country and saying, by simply rezoning that, a new country. Now, simply, that's not so simple. There's going to be, right, certainly public debate.

Julien Andrew Starr: There's going to be constitutional and legal issues that need to be overcome in order to do it cleanly. And just to back up real fast to the Tuvalu example, they are a relatively stable democratic country. There's no dictatorship there. It is a commonwealth country. King Charles III is the ex-officio head of state. So there is that as well, to the extent that matters. And I think it does to a degree.

Julien Andrew Starr: But okay, going back to our hypothetical speculative example, the idea is to transform territory that is not in use, that has little to no obvious strategic value. That is not something where, well, we want to go explore for copper or for ores or different minerals, or we want to go explore for petroleum. There's nothing extracted here. It's all value added. It's by virtue of rezoning this area, it unlocks the potential that is right now not existent by legal fiat.

Julien Andrew Starr: I know that word fiat, the Bitcoin people are going to go crazy, but that's what it is. And so it's pitched as a joint venture, perhaps instead of an outright purchase of territory, which oddly enough is not as easy as people think in terms of the eyes of international law. Believe it or not, there are conventions on alienation of territory. Not that people like Mr. Putin understand this, or he does, but again, I'm not weighing in necessarily good or bad on the Russia-Ukraine situation, but there are very serious conventions about territorial integrity.

Julien Andrew Starr: So what one workaround is a long-term lease. And this is something where the transferring state or the host state, if you will, the landlord state, they're the landlord and they become a landlord. This is the exact opposite of colonialism. This is where we'll pay you. We're going to pay you rent. You're the landlord. You still have title to the land, but we get a long-term lease. And you're recognizing this area. You're giving us a sort of ability to be a separate country.

Julien Andrew Starr: And you're recognizing that by virtue of a constitutive treaty, a bilateral treaty of sorts that would be ratified. And if possible, deposited at the United Nations under their Article 102. That gets to be a matter of the Secretary General deciding to accept it or not. You don't need to be a member of the United Nations to be a signatory, a ratifier of different treaties. One clear example would be the Cook Islands.

Julien Andrew Starr: They are not a member of the United Nations, but they have signed different treaties and had them deposited at the United Nations as an associate state of New Zealand. So it is 100% within the remit and discretion of the Secretary General, but not to go back and not to go too deep into those weeds and not to find these more relatively obscure one-off examples, which maybe prove and maybe not adequately prove. So it does come down to a business proposition. This is where it's imperative to have a symbiotic relationship with the host country.

Julien Andrew Starr: They're getting royalties, they're getting rent, maybe they're even getting equity in the private for-profit companies that administer and operate the basic services for this new country. So they're incentivized to see its success. OK, they have a veritable stake in that. And that also disincentivizes them from doing things that may curtail.

Julien Andrew Starr: And they may not view the new country at its doorstep as a competitor, but as a source of revenue where they can not have to go out there and borrow or tax their own citizens into oblivion in order to maintain their services, their existence, their government. So this is another way of turning something that's a net loser into a net winner, for lack of better words.

Julien Andrew Starr: So, yes, it is very much taking that startup mentality, the capitalist mentality, for lack of better words, and applying it to statecraft, but understanding that you really have to reward all parties concerned. If they're not incentivized, I don't know. And that's just it. But I do know if you incentivize people, you at least have a shot. That's my thinking on the subject.

Timothy Allen: Something that I think is relevant here. This summer, I was in Liberland, actually, and I spoke at their gathering, Liberpolka. And when I was putting my talk together, I thought, oh, I don't know.

Timothy Allen: Let's have a look at what the last countries to be created were you know and just to sort of put Liberland into context right it's quite interesting really because basically modern countries which kind of started in the 20s with places like Pakistan and India and Israel etc you know like to the 1940s kind of area then you get that big burst in the 50s vietnam laos cambodia Ghana, Guinea, lots of African states. And then the 60s is the big independence movement in Africa. You get all those places.

Timothy Allen: Then the 70s, Bangladesh, UAE, Solomon Islands, a big bunch. And then it starts sort of waning off. In the 80s, Belize, St. Kitts and Nevis, Brunei, Namibia. 90s, the whole post-war breakup in the 90s of the cold war breakup and then all of a sudden 2000s to 210s you get four Kosovo Serbia Montenegro Timor East Timor and then the last one was in 2011 and since then we've had nothing.

Timothy Allen: Yeah does that does that tell us anything like does that does that is that is that relevant or are we just waiting for the next big batch to happen

Julien Andrew Starr: I think we're waiting for the next big batch I think that's that's where it is. There are lots of different, I suspect, reasons, and this is just pure speculation. One of them is the makeup of the UN Security Council, right? So the permanent five, US, UK, France, Russian Federation, People's Republic of China. And so they have their thumb on the scale, so to speak. Now, I understand that Kosovo is not a member of the United Nations, And that's very much a case in point. There's a good reason for that.

Julien Andrew Starr: And that is simply because Russia says niet, right? So we know that Russia and Serbia at least were up until maybe recently close allies. Perhaps now with this [unclear] that's in charge in Belgrade, maybe that will change. I don't know. They know there's been some grumblings that perhaps they'll recognize the reality on the ground in Kosovo. But one of the things that I do write about extensively is the tale of two republics, Montenegro and Kosovo. Montenegro is a full member of the United Nations.

Julien Andrew Starr: They are a they're in NATO and they're soon to join the European Union. And again, however people feel about the EU, it is still a mark of acceptance. It's a mark of existence. It's a mark of being something diametrically different than where they had been not too long ago. So the difference between a Montenegro and a Kosovo is that Montenegro had what you often see in international relations, parent-state permission.

Julien Andrew Starr: They had the permission of Belgrade to go ahead and vote for independence, whereas Kosovo did not for a variety of typically historical reasons, as I understand them. Serbia claims historical attachment to Kosovo. The Serbian Orthodox Church, as I understand it, has lots of sites and relics in the area of Kosovo. And so what it is is this, the Russian Federation had no reason to veto, for example, Montenegro's entrance into the United Nations. There was no reason to because Serbia said it was fine by them that Montenegro left. So there was no obstacle there.

Julien Andrew Starr: Just as then conversely nowadays we look at the state of Palestine, as it's often referred to as. And now, more recently, the United Kingdom and the French Republic do recognize Palestine and probably would vote to admit it into the United Nations. But you have a holdup in the form of a certain country between Canada and Mexico, namely the United States of America, which is not keen on allowing Palestine to be more than, as I understand it, an observer in the United Nations. So they are not a full member.

Julien Andrew Starr: And I believe it is the official policy of the United States that they would be in favor of admitting a Palestine as UN member 194 if there were some sort of a permanent peace between them and the state of Israel. And that's their policy. That's the way that they do things. Do I think Kosovo could join the United Nations? Sure. I think it's very possible when Serbia decides they no longer want to claim it as a part of Serbia and they signal to their partners in the Kremlin that it's time.

Julien Andrew Starr: And perhaps there will be some sort of an exchange. Perhaps there will be certain, I don't know, maybe there'll be lifting of sanctions against certain officials in Russia in exchange. Wink, wink, nod, nod, these things happen, you know, provided maybe the hostilities between them and Ukraine simmer down, right? This is just the world of international politics and wranglings and a lot of behind the scenes things that I'm sure many people don't know or can only speculate. So why am I bringing all of this up?

Julien Andrew Starr: Because I think it does serve as a bit of a Rosetta Stone as to why there haven't been more countries coming on the international scene is because these larger powers, in many respects, serve as a bottleneck. And they make it more challenging for that to happen. I do suspect that will be changing, particularly once the Russia-Ukraine situation comes to a bit of a conclusion.

Julien Andrew Starr: Certainly, whether or not this notion of multi-polarity, right, different poles, different powers does come to fruition or not, that may also be something that paves the way for more countries to be recognized and to be able to assert themselves if there are other powers that are willing to lift their light in favor of these new countries coming on the stage. I mean, there is also the case in point of Bougainville over in the Pacific, that part of Papua New Guinea that did vote to become a separate country.

Julien Andrew Starr: It does look to me that they will be joining the community of nations soon, and it's unlikely they will face any sort of a veto from a Russia or a China. Quite the opposite. If anything, the likes of China and Russia probably would be all too eager to recognize a Bougainville to try to get some influence over this new country. And that poses some strategical situations, too.

Julien Andrew Starr: I think a lot of people don't understand what Donald Trump was trying to do vis-à-vis Greenland was not just bravado, was not just the art of the deal, even though supposedly he didn't write that book. It was ghostwritten, but side issue. The concern was that an independent Greenland could come under the spell of Moscow or Beijing. That's what had policy planners in D.C. So concerned. So what are the takeaways here for people that want to run out there and start new countries? You're probably going to be dealing with a larger power at some point.

Julien Andrew Starr: And you're going to need to decide how you want to handle these larger powers. Now, it's very possible, I mentioned that Steve and his deal in Tuvalu, who knows? For all I know, things could be going very beautifully for him. And then someday there's a phone call from Canberra that's placed to Funafuti. And they say the Australian authorities say to their partners in Tuvalu, we really don't like the idea of you recognizing this patch of reclaimed dirt, another country. And there is that possibility.

Julien Andrew Starr: There's also a possibility that Washington or Brussels will make that phone call. These things do happen. They very much happen, and we know that. And anybody that disputes that, there is a very fun case that's very obscure that I'll regale people with very fast. So during the Katanga crisis in the 60s, when the Katanga part of Congo wanted to leave Congo, the newly independent former Belgian Congo, they had tried to offer the Central American country of Costa Rica $1 million to recognize them. Anybody can Google this or run any sort of a search on this.

Julien Andrew Starr: And so the United States intervened and put pressure on the authorities in San Jose, Costa Rica to squash it. They didn't want anyone to go ahead and recognize Katanga on a de jure basis. And so and this is even on the official U.S. State Department Historical Archives website. They don't mention the $1 million part, but they certainly mention that they very actively courted our Latin American partners to not recognize Katanga. And so why am I bringing this up? Because that's the world that we live in. So then what's the solution?

Julien Andrew Starr: The solution is to have friends, to have friends in the UK, France, the United States, and to work with them and to work with them and to be cognizant that they call the shots. And that's the reality of the way it goes. Does it mean you need to be collaborationist? No. Does it mean that you need to serve as some sort of a front or proxy or honeypot for larger powers? No, not necessarily.

Julien Andrew Starr: And that wouldn't do them any good either, because clearly, if if they knew you were nothing, if the world knew you were nothing but a front for the UK or France, then you're not going to be of service to the UK or France either. There needs to be some arm's length separation. So why am I bringing all of this up? Because it's essential to understand the world as it is, not necessarily the way that you want it to be.

Julien Andrew Starr: And to recognize that, you know, forget even the big super superpowers, but even regional bodies, CARICOM in the, what's it, in the Caribbean basin, ECOWAS to an extent in West Africa they call the shots They the ones that keep member states walking a certain path so to speak And so you going to want to get in good with them and to appear to be credible because you got to be credible and transparent. You have to identify how you can be of service to them? What problems can you solve? We go back to the startup mentality.

Julien Andrew Starr: What problems are you solving? What value proposition do you have? These are extraordinarily important keys. And how you can benefit them, how you can make them feel comfortable and not as suspicious and not so hot to make that two o'clock in the morning phone call to a decision maker in a remote capital saying, don't deal with those guys, right?

Timothy Allen: It's interesting as you were speaking there I was just thinking about that list of countries I gave you and when you actually look into it the vast majority of them or at least a lot of them are decolonisation essentially they are it country is taking independence from Portugal Spain, UK, you know. So presumably we are in, I'm trying to think on a global scale, we are in a new era of country making in that sense. You know, I mean, I'm probably missing stuff because I don't think about this stuff as much as you do.

Timothy Allen: But is it, is that a good characterization of the kind of the likely place that new countries are gonna arise now would be that what you've just said it has to be somebody a private company bringing an add a value-add concept to a country? You know, I mean, obviously there are still a few people fighting for sovereignty around the world I'm not saying they're not but on the whole the colonial era, I suppose, is kind of over, is it? I mean, tell me what your view of that is.

Julien Andrew Starr: Yeah I want I do agree with you I think you're totally right it is largely over I do understand that the un has a list of what they call non-self-governing territories and an example that sticks out in my mind is that of Tokelau in the South Pacific. About 1,000 people live there. It's three primary atolls. They have the .tk domain name that they were giving away for free or this Dutch company that had a concession with them were giving it away for free but reserving certain premium ones and making money.

Julien Andrew Starr: But, okay, let's put that aside. They held several, I believe, several different referendums on whether or not to become an associate state of New Zealand, similar to the Cook Islands, for example. And it was narrowly defeated by, I mean, single digits. I think there was something, they were at 65% of the vote and they needed two thirds, as I understand it, to have sent that to New Zealand to be voted upon as an associate state of sorts. So there are very, very few of these non-self-governing territories out there.

Julien Andrew Starr: Certain countries don't like it that some of their more remote territories are on the list. It becomes a very contentious type situation. We're never going to see, for example, Tibet be on that list. That's just never going to happen, right? Because the People's Republic of China is going to say, is going to first of all veto that if they have the opportunity to do so. And they're going to say, no, it's an integral part of China. It always has been. Don't worry about what happened in 1950 or anything like that.

Julien Andrew Starr: And they're within their right legally to say that. So yes, to answer you, yes, the era of decolonisation is largely over. I don't see many situations where we're going to see that many more. Perhaps someday New Caledonia will leave France. It's very possible. Possible. They recently also had a referendum there. But a lot of observers wonder if perhaps Paris didn't exactly put their thumb on the scale there, seeing as something to the tune of 25% of the world's nickel comes from New Caledonia. And it's a relatively strategic place for the French fleet in the Pacific.

Julien Andrew Starr: So that's a matter for people to come to their own conclusions about, so to speak. So yeah, who knows? Maybe down the line, we'll see a few more countries emerge through decolonization efforts. It's very possible. What the Startup States Society advocates for, what I advocate for is we don't even really take a position on that. We don't take a position on Scottish independence. We don't take a position on Welsh independence or Quebec or Alberta leaving. Those are interesting discussion pieces. There's a lot to learn from those examples.

Julien Andrew Starr: It's more the approach of the blank slate, the tabula rasa, the we're going to try to start something from scratch, brand new, without that kind of historical legacy and consideration. So we're looking more at territories and areas that are preferably uninhabited or sparsely inhabited. Because once you start dealing with the displacement of people, first of all, it's wrong. Second of all, it's illegal. It's immoral. It's unethical. You don't want to do that. So this has nothing to do with being a pioneer or a settler or a colonist or any of that.

Julien Andrew Starr: These are or sponsoring and fomenting secession in other countries. These are very, very dangerous propositions. And I personally feel in many respects it would be also unethical to secretly plan. Let me sponsor Quebec independence. This is not a good idea that's up for the people living in those places to make those determinations on their own.

Julien Andrew Starr: I understand the temptation I get it I 100 understand that this is not what startup states are about whatsoever this is very much about so there's this there's a country that has a lot of idle land or perhaps some remote islands let's see if we can't make a deal nobody's living there there are no ancient historical societies no ancestors are buried there there's no it's not the subject of an international dispute.

Julien Andrew Starr: Where you'll have an area that is maybe claimed by multiple different states that's a problem also and that's a that's a liber land problem too is that right Croatia says it's Serbia Serbia says it's Croatia. So that's, you already have two UN member states that are going to disclaim your claim. So that's, that's the thing. You don't want to get embroiled in international disputes because you don't want to run the risk of making a bad situation worse. You don't want people to get hurt. God forbid that you just, you can't, I'm out.

Julien Andrew Starr: I mean, if anybody wants to advocate for that I'm out

Timothy Allen: You know what in this movement the Free Cities movement at least there's often chatter of large places breaking up into their smaller components you know and I know that the colonial element of that may may be over but what's your view on the general state of very large places I'm thinking China, maybe the US, maybe Russia. Do we expect at some point to see those kind of places fragment?

Timothy Allen: It does appear that it might be a kind of life cycle of the state in a way you know if we if we look back into history I suppose we can see states grow very large and then die, basically. And that's that's a heartbeat in in the historical context. Obviously, I'm not saying that giving you a time scale here, but are we to expect that at some point these very large behemothic states will break up?

Julien Andrew Starr: I mean I mean certainly anything is possible The Soviet Union is a great classic example That an easy one to just point to And it still amazing that it happened the way that it did And that story isn't entirely over as contemporary headlines seem to suggest and do very much suggest Do I see, for example, Texas leaving the United States? I wouldn't put too much money on it. I don't see any part of the United States breaking away, so to speak. I do think we could see very real active movements and greater pressures.

Julien Andrew Starr: I know recently the Canadian province of Alberta held some sort of a referendum on whether or not to pursue a possible referendum on independence down the line, and that was defeated. I think we're living in that situation where there's what is equal and opposite reactions, right? So as there's this great coming together as countries such as Montenegro want to join the European Union, and certainly Albania would love to, North Macedonia. You also conversely see countries within that union that want to break free, right? The Corsican separatists that want to leave France at the same time.

Julien Andrew Starr: Other countries want to join the very club that France is a part of. So there is that. As there's greater push toward globalization and homogenization, so to speak, I think invariably people will want to seek out different expressions of their own identity. And so, yes, we'll probably see those movements intensify, certainly as globalism and transnationalism accelerate. That I very much do see. The trick is, though, what does it really look like to go on your own?

Julien Andrew Starr: What would it look like to have, I mean, look at all the pain that Brexit has reportedly caused the UK and there's wrangling about maybe joining the EU again. So what does the next day look like? I think that's one of the questions. But then, you know, you start to say, well, are we just staying with the devil we know versus maybe going for something much better? Maybe it doesn't have to be this way.

Julien Andrew Starr: Or are some peoples stuck in a sort of Stockholm-like syndrome where, well, you know, maybe we shouldn't vote for independence because we don't really know any better. We like the way things really are. We can't envision a better life potentially should we choose to vote for independence or self-government. But do I see the breakup of bigger states? Not anytime soon, because I think they have successfully incentivized and inoculated themselves against a lot of these things.

Julien Andrew Starr: And for all the faults of these larger powers, they still do a reasonably good job of keeping the baseline of quality of life there and afloat. Yeah, sure, there's a hollowing out of the middle class and certain places infrastructure is lacking. And there are lots of easy things to point to. But by and large, it's not a matter of human survival for people to say, well, that was really great to be a part of this, this bigger power. We're just going to we're just going to go our own way now. Right. And that's it.

Julien Andrew Starr: So I think that, right, we're comfortably numb, so to speak. And I think there is an element of that at play. So no, I don't really see the larger powers disintegrating just yet. If they were to push, if conditions, economic conditions in particular, were to fall apart, I think anything's possible. I also am of the view that if this push towards further globalization and integration accelerates, you never know. Someone somewhere might say, It's too much. It's too fast. We need to slam the brakes on this. So it's all possible.

Julien Andrew Starr: But usually these are economic decisions that are dressed up as cultural issues. And I say this not to be cynical, but real fast, the Quebec movement in particular was largely not very serious about independence. And I understand they held a referendum in 1980 and then in 95, the 95 one notably being less than 50,000 votes for separation from Canada. But the underlying idea was if we can scare the national authority, if we can scare the federal government of Canada, federal Canada into thinking we're going to leave, maybe they'll give us more money.

Julien Andrew Starr: Maybe they'll give us more subsidies. Maybe they'll give us more goodies or they'll do some some favor for us. So in many cases, it's a it's a game of brinksmanship. Excuse me. So I think that in many instances, that's what's going on here. I mean, the core separatists in Corsica, many of them are very serious and sincere, but a lot of them are looking for a better deal on cigarettes and gasoline, to be fair about it. So there is that. And again, I'm not trying to throw anyone under the bus.

Julien Andrew Starr: I know there are people that have legitimate grievances, and I don't mean to state explicitly that everything's about euros and cents.

Timothy Allen: What about briefly then, giving me a quick overview of the startup state's landscape? Let's not go over the ground we've already gone, Liberland being one, Tuvalu, probably Próspera. Would you class prosper in that realm? Or are your startup states really independent places?

Julien Andrew Starr: So to answer you, there are remarkably few startup states that are conspicuous. You're right. We did go over Steve Clancy's Tuvalu situation to be sure. There's another gentleman by the name of Boris Reitman, R-E-I-T-M-A-N. He's out there publicly, and his organization is Anthemism. He takes his cue from Ayn Rand and her novel novella Anthem. And so his idea is to try and start an Ayn Rand-inspired country, if you will.

Julien Andrew Starr: He recently flew out to Cyprus, of all places, to participate in a film very much on the subject of those people that are out there trying to start new countries, new polities. There are several people that are conspicuously publicly working on such things. I think there are many more that are doing so more privately for a variety of different reasons. Reasons presumably they feel that maybe working behind the scenes is to their advantage.

Julien Andrew Starr: I personally am of the view that it's better to be out in the open and transparent about things, very similar to the old Free Society group that had registered in the Isle of Man, as I understand, freesociety.com. I believe that's now just accessible on the Wayback Machine. This was a group headed up by the likes of Olivier Janssen and Roger Ver of all people. And their idea was to try to buy their way into nationhood, statehood. So these types of arrangements have happened even more recently where people have attempted this.

Julien Andrew Starr: But as for specific startup states, there are not very many. So what's the deal here then? What happened was to sort of backtrack a little bit. When I first attended the Liberty in Our Lifetime conference in Prague 2024, when it was called that, as I understand it, it's the Free Cities Foundation Conference. What occurred to me was it's fantastic that there's this foundation of professional people, of driven people that are pursuing the creation of new cities and things along those wavelengths.

Julien Andrew Starr: And so why isn't there a comparable organization for those that want to run out there and start new countries? Because This is something that had long been on my mind. And so it occurred to me, why not set up the very organization that you yourself would want to be in contact with when you're ready to go out there and start your own new country? And that was very much how the Startup States Society was built. It's a very new organization, barely even a year and a half old.

Julien Andrew Starr: And so we have not had many different people approach us yet, and we haven't approached a good deal of people either that are actively publicly trying to start new countries. Would I include the likes of Próspera in there? Not so much because they don't exactly have national aspirations.

Julien Andrew Starr: And so that's something to take into consideration that they, They are not interested in doing that But let see And I wouldn necessarily put Liberland in there as well because Liberland is they're not working in conjunction as far as I understand it with any other existing UN member state. They are, they declare themselves to be Liberland and they declare themselves to be independent. And So I'm sure they would love to work with existing UN member states.

Julien Andrew Starr: I know they certainly have tried, but thus far, to my knowledge, they have not publicly been successful in doing so. So it's very much in the approach. The approach is to work first and foremost with existing UN member states. So we have the example you mentioned of the Network School in Malaysia. Maybe it would have been a little bit better if they had closer relations with the authorities in Malaysia. Maybe they would have been able to head off what ultimately happened. Perhaps they were the victim of circumstance. It could very well be.

Julien Andrew Starr: Maybe they were set up. Maybe they were framed. I genuinely don't know. But I do know that their approach with Kazakhstan is exactly on point and exactly right. And that is you work with the existing state apparatus from the onset and you negotiate accordingly. So would I put them on the list of a startup state? I don't think they have national aspirations, excuse me. So that's one of the determining factors is does the initiative, does the endeavor see themselves as a country or a potential country?

Julien Andrew Starr: And are they working with recognized counterparties to effectuate that goal? So to answer the question, there are hardly, there are very, very few, but we are now starting to open up the Startup States Society and soliciting people that are interested in doing this to have a chat. And so that's starting to happen as we're raising the visibility of the Startup States Society.

Julien Andrew Starr: We are starting to have those types of communications and chats with people that are serious about doing this and that have clear ideas that want to bring about the creation of new countries in a peaceful, ethical, and lawful manner. Those are really the big three.

Timothy Allen: Just finally, before we finish, you just mentioned Olivier Janssen there.

Julien Andrew Starr: Ah, yes.

Timothy Allen: And his project, Destiny. There was a lot of talk about it about, I don't know, six months, maybe eight months ago. I haven't looked into it again. Recently. Do you know much about what's going on over there?

Julien Andrew Starr: I get asked this question often and no, the short answer is I don't know. I hear chatter. I constantly hear chatter about it. I know there's been some discussion that they are building some sort of a dialysis center, a medical center on the island of Nevis and that they are continuing. They have broken ground, apparently. I was under the impression that they had not, but apparently they have. I know there has been some controversy about it being a state within a state.

Julien Andrew Starr: My understanding of Olivier, and I've never crossed paths with him, is that he very much has long championed the idea of starting new countries. My suspicion with respect to Destiny is perhaps he has resigned himself that this is the best that he can do at this time. It's a thought. Because for a long time, when one would go to Destiny.com, I don't know if it's still the case, I think under their FAQ, this is not a new country initiative or whatever, however they phrase it. And it's sort of curious to even put that in there.

Julien Andrew Starr: Why would you bother putting that in there? And I think that is born out of perhaps concerns that locals have about it being a country within a country. But I think it's more so because Olivier and some of the other members of Free Society, his previous initiative, are now involved with with Destiny. I don't think they are attempting at seeding from Nevis or St. Kitts and Nevis. I don't think it is some sort of a front for a new country project of any kind. I don't think so. I doubt very much that's the case.

Julien Andrew Starr: Certainly, he and many of his colleagues do have the financial resources to pull off pretty much whatever. They want. So there is that. But no, I have not heard anything concrete that I can corroborate. But I know that certainly has made the rounds, especially in light of lots of the tumult that Próspera has been having. So I understand some people are thinking, well, maybe Destiny would be a good place to go to if Próspera doesn't manage to stay afloat vis-à-vis Honduras.

Timothy Allen: It does appear that the sort of billionaire backed idea is is one of the more powerful ones at the moment. As I mentioned at the beginning of this episode we've just seen Palmer Luckey come out and say exactly the same thing with regards to seasteading which and you know he's basically talking about the fact that for the last seven years they've been designing a floating city. So it's I think it's seven years anyway. So it's definitely one of the stronger narratives.

Timothy Allen: Anyway, Julien, look I'd love to carry on I think it's time to knock it on the head this time. But almost certainly I'd love to have you back on at another stage I know we've just hit the tip of the iceberg here.

Timothy Allen: And we haven't really gone super deep yet but now I'm doing this midweek show I think there'll be many more options to talk in the future so thanks very much for coming on and obviously where do we send people who are interested in this that your organization and startup states in general let's say yeah

Julien Andrew Starr: Startupstates.swiss is where one can find us or startupstates.com will redirect you to the official website at startupstates.swiss and there are five published monographs that I wrote some with help, some not with help. Two are undergoing peer review, which should be really interesting. We have two atlases, one for unrecognized states, past and present, and also another atlas, states that have received limited recognition. So you'll find Somaliland in there that has been recognized more recently by Israel. So they're now in that atlas, and there are data sets. It's all free. People can use it.

Julien Andrew Starr: We've had some researchers, some scholars that have reached out to us, which is pretty nice. And that's a good vote of confidence, so to speak. So they're welcome to do that. If people want to get in touch with me personally, I maintain a website at starr.mc. So my personal site is starr.mc. And most people just call me Andy for short because it's a little bit easier.

Julien Andrew Starr: But, yeah, and I'm available whenever to discuss matters involving statehood and country formation and starting new countries with all those that are looking to do something great and that want to get that gold medal we were talking about before.

Timothy Allen: Good. Here's to gold medals. Anyway, thanks, Julian. Great. Thanks, Andy, I should say. Sorry.

Julien Andrew Starr: That's okay. Thank you.

Timothy Allen: Well, why don't you actually, before you go, what is the difference between Julian, Andrew and star stars, obviously your, your surname, but why are they, why are they?

Julien Andrew Starr: That's my middle name. And just people call me Andy. Right. My middle name is Andrew. So people just call me Andy. It's a, I respond to both. It's perfectly fine. And I think just being a lot, a lot more casual and down to earth is just the way to do things. And I don't demand that people call me Andrew or Julien. It's also really difficult for people to pronounce.

Timothy Allen: Oh, Julien. I was even getting that wrong as well.

Julien Andrew Starr: No, no, no, no. You're perfectly fine. You know what it is? It's difficult for people to pronounce the U in the French language. So Andy is just a lot easier. And Andrew really is my middle name. So it works out beautifully. There's no problem there. But it really is a tremendous honor, Tim. There's no question you're you're a legend a living legend as they say and it's been

Timothy Allen: A tremendous honor really though thank you I'm not sure I'm a living legend but certainly enjoy being in the Free City space as you obviously do as well so that I know we're we're well I say we're small we kind of are there's a lot of people that think about it I think we're certainly not not a large group of people but we're definitely growing yes yeah I know it is and it's beautiful to see

Julien Andrew Starr: So many dedicated sincere people that have made this not just a weekend thing that they think about. But an everyday career on a very professional level it's quite amazing to see that absolutely

Timothy Allen: Andy well thanks and I'll look forward to speaking to you another time thank you cheers okay

Julien Andrew Starr: Thank you.

Explore more conversations about how places govern themselves on the Free Cities Podcast with Timothy Allen at freecities.fm.

Watch more conversations on Timothy Allen’s YouTube channel.

Related conversations