Episode 210

Can You Really Escape the Government at Sea? | O. Shane Balloun

Published

"At some point, the sea will have become an inevitable place for population. We're not there yet, but I think it is inevitable. The question is on what timeline and with what technology jumps. And of course, that will invite more in different types of governance."

Can you escape bad government by moving your home out to sea?

A floating home gives its owner an unusual option: if the rules become intolerable, move the home. Timothy Allen has come to see that mobility as one of seasteading’s strongest advantages. American maritime lawyer O. Shane Balloun joins him to examine the legal reality behind the promise.

Balloun’s research into American law-enforcement jurisdiction over seasteads was published in the University of San Francisco Maritime Law Journal in 2012. At the start of this conversation, he explains how that work reached The Seasteading Institute through Patri Friedman, and how he later learnt that it had helped inspire Joe Quirk’s involvement in seasteading. Balloun practises admiralty and maritime law at Balloun Law Professional Corporation.

Recorded in Próspera in September 2026, the interview moves from flags and offshore boundaries to a harder question: what happens when the rules offer protection but a government has the power to ignore them?

Why this conversation matters now

On 18 November 2026, Palmer Luckey described SLAB, a seastead he is developing with the aim of providing industrial space beyond restrictive state and local regulation. He says its ambitions extend to manufacturing, medical research and desalination, and that the project still has a long way to go. His announcement brings fresh attention to the question running through this interview: how much freedom does moving offshore actually buy?

Twelve miles out does not mean no government

Timothy begins with a common assumption: once you are far enough from the beach, you are beyond the state’s reach. Balloun takes apart that assumption by distinguishing territorial waters, the contiguous zone and the exclusive economic zone. Under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea, a territorial sea can extend up to twelve nautical miles from the relevant baseline and a contiguous zone up to twenty-four. An exclusive economic zone can reach two hundred nautical miles. Each involves different rights and powers.

The conversation explores the practical consequences for travelling, fishing, extracting resources and living on a floating structure. Balloun separates the rules for civilians from questions of military force. Timothy presses the uncomfortable hypothetical: even if a floating city has found a workable legal arrangement, what would prevent a powerful country from intervening?

What a flag can do for a floating home

A vessel’s flag connects it to a national legal system. Balloun explains why he considers registration an important safeguard, and why operating without a flag can expose a seastead to interventions from multiple states. He also distinguishes a vessel from a fixed structure, since the classification affects which legal questions arise.

At the September recording, Balloun described progress towards flagging a seastead in Panama under a new classification. He was hopeful that the process could become repeatable, while stressing that the arrangement was not yet fully perfected. The discussion concerns that developing route, rather than an established registration service available to every aspiring seasteader.

Different laws on neighbouring platforms

Joe Quirk’s example of a floating community with several jurisdictions side by side sounds attractive: work on one platform, socialise on another, and choose the rules that suit each activity. Timothy wonders whether the arrangement would look like an invitation to close a loophole.

Balloun uses medical tourism to show that crossing between legal systems already happens on land. But proximity at sea could create difficult interactions. His hypothetical Singaporean and Dutch platforms illustrate the possibility that conduct permitted on one vessel could still create problems when a person returns to another. A line on the deck would not settle every question of jurisdiction.

The law is not a spell book

The interview’s central warning reaches well beyond seasteading. Balloun discusses “sovereign citizen” arguments and the belief that the right words can remove a court’s authority. He is sympathetic to the desire for freedom, but rejects the idea that legal language works like an incantation.

For him, the rule of law depends on people and institutions agreeing to follow rules even when doing so is inconvenient. Timothy asks whether older common-law principles might still provide an escape. Balloun describes the distance between discovering an appealing historical principle and persuading a present-day court to recognise it.

Could governments compete for seasteaders?

The distinction between maritime law and the law of the sea leads into the incentives behind vessel registration. Balloun describes maritime law’s treatment of ships, owners, liabilities and commercial disputes, then returns to the treaties and customary practices governing relations between states.

Timothy is particularly interested in flag registries as a competitive market. Countries want shipping business, while reputable operators want passengers to remain safe. They discuss whether those incentives can produce useful rules, and whether a similar relationship could develop between floating communities and the countries whose flags they use.

Leaving, belonging and the purpose of government

Stories about Sealand lead into a broader discussion of shared expectations and respect for the law. Timothy considers the choice between staying to fight for change and leaving for somewhere that treats its residents better. Balloun returns to mobility: a floating homeowner could, at least in principle, take the home elsewhere instead of selling up.

The final part of the interview examines free speech, the American Constitution and the idea that rights exist before a government recognises them. Timothy describes the appeal of having a constitutional protection an individual can invoke against the state. Balloun explains his view of natural rights and the Bill of Rights, before setting out the purposes for which he believes government can be legitimate: collective defence and responding to fundamental wrongdoing.

Read and explore

Supporting the show

Lead show sponsor Veritas Villages develops freedom-oriented communities in Panama, Costa Rica and Nicaragua. The show is also supported by AmityAge. Join the newsletter for new conversations and updates.

Enjoy the conversation.

Audio version

Includes Timothy Allen’s introduction and additional commentary not included in the video.

210 - Can You Really Escape the Government at Sea? | O. Shane Balloun

Follow Timothy Allen on YouTube

Subscribe for upcoming films and conversations about the people building freer societies.

Subscribe on YouTube

In this episode

  • Seasteading and the ability to move a home between jurisdictions
  • Territorial waters, contiguous zones and exclusive economic zones
  • Flags, stateless vessels and the limits of registration
  • Prospective Panama registration arrangements discussed in September 2026
  • Different legal systems on neighbouring floating platforms
  • Sovereign citizen arguments and the difference between law and power
  • Maritime law, treaties and customary international law
  • Competition between flag registries and incentives for safety
  • Sealand, shared norms and the choice to leave
  • The Constitution, natural rights, free speech and collective defence
Read transcript

Timothy Allen: Do I call you O. Shane?

O. Shane Balloun: Yes.

Timothy Allen: I have never heard of a name that was O before. What's that? Explain that.

O. Shane Balloun: It's a first initial and a middle name.

Timothy Allen: All right. So out of interest, why have you adopted that? Is that it?

O. Shane Balloun: It was adopted for me as a baby. My parents called me that since the time I was born.

Timothy Allen: Really? And what does the O stand for?

O. Shane Balloun: It stands for Oral, which is a name on my dad's side.

Timothy Allen: So if you were to go back to, which country is that name from then, Oral? Is that a Celtic name or something like that?

O. Shane Balloun: No, I assume that it's, I think it's French or Swiss French. And it comes from Aurelius.

Timothy Allen: Oh, right.

O. Shane Balloun: But yeah.

Timothy Allen: Marcus Aurelius.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah. O-R-A-L. And so it's a name on my dad's side and he insisted that it'd be part of my name, but my parents couldn't name me S-O-B so they put the O in front.

Timothy Allen: So when but when you when someone shouts if someone sees you at a train station, do they shout O or do they shout?

O. Shane Balloun: O. Shane. O. Shane.

Timothy Allen: They do shout O. Shane. Okay.

O. Shane Balloun: As if it were Irish, but it's, and I'm a little bit Irish, but it's false advertising to the extent that it implies that I'm that Irish.

Timothy Allen: I did call you Shane in an email, so I'll apologise now. But Joe, of you, said, 'He wrote the foundational paper that made me decide to get involved in seasteading.' So, and I and I actually blamed Joe for getting a lot of people in trouble in seasteading. He's basically caused a lot of people to completely change their lives and go off and do completely ridiculous things. So in a way, you've got one up on him because you actually made him get involved in seasteading.

O. Shane Balloun: It's incredible. He told me that very recently. We were traveling together and he revealed that to me, and I had no idea. So, it's always interesting to know what one's work is going to turn into. You may never know, right?

Timothy Allen: So, did you predate Joe in seasteading or.

O. Shane Balloun: I suppose technically I did. Yeah. Patri Friedman, and I have known each other for a long time and we're friendly acquaintances and we used to work together at the same company, and I approached him at random when I was finishing law school, and I said, Hey, I've written this paper on the law of the sea. And I decided to make it about seasteading because I was doing an independent study and thought it would be fun. Grist for the mill, so to speak. And I just sent it to him out of the blue, which was fun because my law professor who was overseeing it thought it should be published. And he found it quite interesting. And, so I sent it to Patri and Patri was like, We'd love to have that on our website. And so then I eventually published it probably about half a year later with the University of San Francisco Maritime Law Journal. And yeah.

Timothy Allen: But the interesting thing, I've been on a journey with seasteading myself from thinking it was a cute idea. That sounds cool. To actually having the whole thing dismantled by Joe over the years. Like I say, we've had some very long deep conversations about it to the point now where I actually see it not only as inevitable as in the kind of grand scale version of seasteading but being the best and most pure model of a private city. So whereas before, because, you know a lot of people talk about private cities here and this, you know on land essentially, and I always used to think yeah there's private cities that's the model, and then there's seasteading. But actually when you think about it there's seasteading, and then there's private cities on land because they are a second order. They're not as good. You can't move them. You can't move cities on land, you know the original idea of a city which is the most immune to say the state for example, it would be a floating city or possibly a city in space floating around maybe, but we're not there yet. At least, you know, we're sort of close to seasteading. So, yeah, I've gone completely full circle now. I think it's the most important idea at least in I know it's in its early stages and everyone's on a small individual scale. There's a lot of things being built, but I would say that it's inevitable that large-scale seasteading projects occur unless we have some kind of weird communist authoritarian world government that really clamps down on it. But even that would be very difficult. I'm sure you've probably got something to say on that because I think probably I don't know exactly what how much of a reach the state has to get out to you. Say when you're more than 12 miles out or you're 24 miles out or you're 200 miles out. Maybe you could sort of start by breaking that down for us because I think most people think as long as you're 12 miles outside of town or out off the beach, you're good. But I get the sense that's not strictly true.

O. Shane Balloun: That is almost totally not true.

Timothy Allen: Oh, okay. There you go. But that is the general consensus, I think. Like, so I'd love to clear it up, and then I'll start saying exactly what you tell me now I will start saying from now on.

O. Shane Balloun: It's funny. Well that's very interesting. I hope that I'm right. And I first was, as you were talking, wasn't sure if you wanted me to discuss jurisprudential philosophy or the pragmatic effects of the current international regime as it stands. So I guess I'll start with the latter. In general, every state has fundamental political authority over the territorial waters extending 12 miles out, 12 nautical miles out from their coast.

Timothy Allen: Sure, nautical miles.

O. Shane Balloun: You know, which are functionally 6,000 feet. Each mile is 6,000 feet. So 12 miles is 96,000 feet away from the shore. Beyond that, the, each state has the ability to investigate violations of its customs laws and its customs waters, in what is also known as a contiguous zone, 24 miles out from the coastline. And where borders of states meet you subtend a line that's sort of tangent to both state borders out sort of indefinitely, and that becomes the border for each state or each nation, and they can govern accordingly. That's essentially the law as it stands with respect to engaging in investigations and investigatory stops of vessels in those waters. Beyond that you have the 200 mile EEZ which allows for the state to control or the nation state to control development and resource collection from the continental shelf. And so if you're beyond 24 miles, but let's say you're at 30 miles or 90 miles, you can engage in, you can travel and be unmolested, right, by theoretically by a nation state, except if you're extracting resources from the continental seabed. And to some extent also fishing. So ultimately, there's still a lot of control that nation states have, you know, quite a few miles from shore.

Timothy Allen: When you hear stories on the news of Chinese trawlers in the Western Hemisphere, in the wrong place, is that the 200 mile one or is that less?

O. Shane Balloun: That's, I mean, they're almost definitely going to be on the continental shelf fishing and trying to exploit the seas for all their worth. And, you know, ultimately, I think that some of the nations could push back. They're not doing it necessarily off the coast of the United States, because the Coast Guard would get involved. But are they doing it in South America? Sure, Because the political power, political will of South American countries is quite less to resist China.

Timothy Allen: So talking of South America, well, talking about America, Central America, another thing that obviously appeared in the news recently was Trump just steamed into, was blowing up vessels off the coast of Venezuela, places like that. How does that work? Is that just out now illegal?

O. Shane Balloun: Well, I don't think so. Not necessarily. I mean, ultimately, he's the commander in chief of the United States and was executing a military operation. So, whether the military operation was, quote unquote, illegal is really a different question than can civilians engage in certain types of behaviors. It's not even the same type of question.

Timothy Allen: All right. But in the context of seasteading, let's say, there is a hypothetical situation where a big city floats off the coast, 200 miles off the coast, or however many miles off the coast of California, and is offering a service that they really don't like in America. Arguably, I'm not sure that would really happen. I don't know how much people would really care, but they could potentially go in and just blow it up.

O. Shane Balloun: Absolutely.

Timothy Allen: And that's never going to change. That's always going to be the case.

O. Shane Balloun: That's never going to change.

Timothy Allen: Right. So, okay. Well, it's good to make, it's good to play that ground.

O. Shane Balloun: I mean, it could change at some point if the United States declines, right? But it's, the fact of the matter is that might makes right in the world. It's not moral per se. It's not immoral per se. But as a utilitarian matter, might makes right.

Timothy Allen: But it's, yeah, I'm trying to hone my sense of the model, which is still the most perfect model of a private city, I think, that evades, that keeps sovereignty. It's the sovereign model on that scale. But there's nothing that's going to stop another sovereign just coming in and bombing you. Legally speaking, there's no legality at that level.

O. Shane Balloun: Well, and so let's back up for a second. The international framework of international law is really about sovereigns among one another. It's not about individuals or even cities or communities. It's about nation states because it was set up within the context of the Westphalian nation state framework from literally the 1600s. And the idea, right, is that all these princes, and I say that all these monarchs, all these heads of state, arrogated to themselves the control of the entire world, right? And certainly dividing up the land according to what they believed their divine right was the first order of business. And because the sea was necessarily this, you know, ephemeral amorphous thing that's hard to control except through direct exertion of power. And, you know, that's why you had the Spanish Armada, and then the English Navy. Because of that eventually the framework around the sea grew to be, you can see from the way that it developed that it acknowledges the fact that the sea is hard to control. But there's an attempt by all the Westphalian nation states to control it, which is why you cannot have stateless vessels on the sea. I mean, you can float a vessel and go wherever you want. But if you're not flying a flag representing a nation state, then you are subject to the concurrent jurisdiction of all nation states everywhere in the world all at once. So if you are sailing a stateless vessel, whether that's a pleasure vessel, a container ship, a future mode of seastead, and you have no flag, you will be stopped by the United States Coast Guard or the Navy, and you may also be stopped by the Mongolian Navy or the Cameroonian Navy or the South African Navy or the Turkish Navy. Or what have you, anywhere in the world. So how is that and why is that possible? It's only possible by the assertion of nation state power through the further assertion of treaties concluded by member states who simply arrogate to themselves the power to do so. But it's literally arbitrary, but because that's the way these nation states consent to sort of work together, that's the way it is. So ultimately, when it comes down to it, the whole system is based on an assertion of power, which is why back to your earlier question, you know, if a country wants to, I mean, bomb a seastead, it sounds horrific, but if they do want to, they'll get away with it. So ultimately, I've always thought that the ideal way to approach seasteading is to be as amenable and friendly as one can be and cooperative. You still want to assert and develop legal framework so that people who are, people, I say people, entities, nations, who are willing to abide by the framework will respect other entities abiding by the framework.

Timothy Allen: I was just watching Joe's talk on the live feed then he talked about a particular scenario that could happen in the future, and I was just wondering what your opinion on it was because when I when I first discovered about the flagging idea. It seems great but it also seems like it's a little bit of a scam sometimes like you just pick a country that suits you. I know in the in the world of alternative governments, it's amazing, but really in the world of very normal legal things, it's quite obviously a way to sort of get around certain things. That's what it struck me as anyway. And I'll give you the example. So Joe talked about a large seastead out at sea that was split into quadrants all with different flags. So you go to you go to the office in the Singapore one, and then you, and then you go for a beer and a joint in the I don't know the Dutch one. The Yeah. Wherever right and blah. Right. Okay. Theoretically possible but it pushes that boundary a little bit more when you look at that. And When I look at that, I think that looks that's that's exposed using the kind of inverted comma scam of it. Because that does seem weird that you would just walk from literally over to another thing. And I suspect that might draw more attention to the fact that things like that push the envelope too much. What do you think about that?

O. Shane Balloun: It's a complex question. So let me try to break it down. Fundamentally that issue already exists with respect to landed nation states, right? You can walk across the border from one nation to another with different laws and act differently and remain legal within the second nation that you've crossed into. Whereas maybe in your first nation, your activity was not legal. Let's take let's take a soft example that's not going to ruffle too many feathers. Let talk about medical tourism. right? So there may be procedures in the United States that are not FDA approved and therefore doctors cannot undertake or prescribe or perform them. That doesn't mean that they're immoral. They're just not allowed. They're not lawful yet. They may be in the future. But you can cross over into South America and engage in medical tourism to your own benefit, and then come back to the United States and no one is going to judge you or think the worse of you or even investigate you because you haven't violated any U.S. laws and you've taken advantage of the allowance in the South American country to engage in that sort of medical behavior. So that already exists. The issue, right, is that people don't think very clearly about that distinction. I don't think that clear distinction will be applied to seasteads because people, because they're new and societies are trepidatious or they have a jaundiced eye towards new things, ultimately you're going to see criticism or questions just like you've described where those questions would not be fairly applied in the land-to-land context. So with that aside, one of my concerns with the idea of having say the four quadrants is that every single one of the countries that has the that has a flag over their vessel. And then also let's set aside the fact that seasteads don't necessarily have to be vessels, but if they are vessels, then they need to be flagged. And if they are flagged, then each flagging country has primary jurisdiction over each of its vessels. And let's say you have the Singaporean vessel connected temporarily to the Dutch vessel and the Singaporean or the person on the Singaporean vessel leaves and goes to the Dutch vessel, and then uses marijuana, and then comes back to the Singaporean vessel. I don't think that's a problem for, I mean, I can't speak to Dutch law, but my sense is that's probably not a problem. Theoretically though I don't know if the regulations about vessels at sea include drug use etc. They probably do but we'll assume that's legal on the Dutch side. You go back to Singapore. Now, Singapore has a vested interest in controlling its vessel according to its own internal laws and it may prosecute or punish that person even though what they did was completely legal on the other vessel, theoretically. But they come back and now Singapore might even suggest, hey, you've committed, not only have you committed something illegal and you've brought that back to our vessel, You did it elsewhere, but we're going to exert jurisdiction because you were just kind of down the street, you know, 45 feet away. But now we're going to consider the people that you engaged, that you purchased marijuana from to be engaged in a conspiracy to sell or traffic drugs in Singapore, right? So I don't, there are a lot of internal domiciled laws that can be brought to bear on the sea just because of their vessels flagging that have not, those interactions have not been worked out very well.

Timothy Allen: It just struck me as the kind of thing that would ruffle, no matter what it was, it would ruffle feathers. I mean, you can take it to an extreme and say age of consent, you know things that really do get people ruffled, and I would imagine that state response in the end would be, no, you just can't do that if you see what I mean. You just can't have suddenly Singapore next to, you know next to the opposite of Singapore somewhere like Holland, you know which is far less [unclear]. But you literally get killed in Singapore if [unclear] there's the death penalty for trafficking isn't it and it's the complete opposite, so I don't know it's an interesting thought experiment because obviously me personally yeah I want I want Joe's version where you just take a step in that direction and all of a sudden the laws change. But what it starts doing to the human mind, especially the kind of the kind of government workers mind is it makes them think, hold a minute, that's not right. Even though it is right, how can you do that? Because it just it's too ethereal. It's too it's like a lot of these places where you get e-residency and this than that. And it's all kind of going on in the ether. And people like you, and I might say, Yeah, of course. But that's the reality of it. But I think your average person who thinks about a country as having a border with a with a wall or a fence or at least something in a seastead like that you can literally just change a jurisdiction with nothing really. You don't you don't you just put a line on the floor if you really wanted to, you know.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah. And this really runs into what the law really is. So let's take a step back from the sea, right? Take a step back from the land. Law is an assertion of power and typically in an ordered manner, right? So, ultimately, the law is not magic, right? You don't cast spells. This is a problem I see with, say, sovereign citizens, right? Have you heard of sovereign citizens?

Timothy Allen: No, I haven't.

O. Shane Balloun: It's a U.S. phenomenon where people who have been convinced, and I'll just say by the internet, that their birth certificate is a lien against their body, and the government controls it, and they can release themselves and not pay taxes and do all this other stuff, right? And if they say the right words in court, they can be magically absolved of jurisdiction. And it's very frustrating for practitioners because it's all nonsense. Now, I have a lot of sympathy for people who engage in this kind of behavior because they're not trained in the law to know well enough as to what they believed is true. And they ultimately want freedom, which of course I sympathize with. But the problem is they go into court, for example, and they'll start the script, the spewing the script of words as if the law were a magical spell or a set of spells. And then they think that if they say the right thing, then they will gain their outcome, which is absolution from jurisdiction or divestment of jurisdiction over them and they can walk away. And that's not true. And the reason it's not true is because the law is an assertion of power. That's it, right? If the jurisdiction they were in had no means of arresting them, they wouldn't care. They'd just walk away. So they're hoping that by incanting these magical spells while they're in court, they can convince the power that is to let them go. And if we're not clear on that, right, seasteading or any other engagement of an attempt to live in a free manner or a more free manner can get caught up in the same problematic thinking. You always have to remember that this is an assertion of power by nation states, and they agree to interact with you, interact with their citizens, interact with others, foreign nationals, etc., based on a set of rules. And what creates the rule of law is that society as a whole says we will abide by these rules even if they're uncomfortable. And to a great extent, nations have, I mean, over time have allowed the decay of rule of law, right? They're no longer necessarily engaging with the law as a set of rules and instead are using the law as an assertion or a twist of power to force an outcome. And so long as that's true to any extent, you must be clear-minded about, say, what seasteading is and could be. Yes, in the theoretical most positive outcome, what Joe is talking about is correct. And it sounds like a lovely world where you can choose the best of each jurisdiction. But nation states also sometimes have a vested interest to force you to choose the worst of their jurisdictions. And so how do you ensure that the framework that you have will benefit you and the people that are in your societies, your seasteads, the best? And that's going to be an incremental work in progress, understanding that there are always going to be competing incentives and game theoretical mechanisms and outcomes. And politics is the main one with respect to every nation state. So that's complicated, but ultimately I want seasteaders to be careful, right? On one hand, you have to just, you have to, the only way that you make progress is by stepping out in faith. And on the other hand, right, just be, just be, what's the word I'm looking for? Yeah, clear-minded about what you're up against, right? People's expectations over a societal basis will form political opinions, and you're going to have to fight against that, in a way that, and maintain your composure and dignity and moral truth and righteousness and hope that you can convince people that ultimately you're on the right side of things.

Timothy Allen: When you were talking about those kind of those little things that turn up on Facebook every now, and then, which is if you declare this on Facebook, you can, oh, that's what you're talking about.

O. Shane Balloun: Sort of, yeah. But they're in the same vein.

Timothy Allen: Right. Are there any instances I mean are those based in any kind of reality. And if so, because common law might allow something like that to sort of like end up instantiated, right? Is that right? Could it? I mean, someone comes up with these and they're not all viral scams, are they? Some of them are people sitting down and saying, I'm a sovereign individual. I just am. And here's how I can show privately sorry publicly that I am because if you track this back far enough to the 1400s when people started birth I don't know whatever either birth certificates and all that kind of stuff. Presumably that's what common law is for potentially to rectify things like that. I don't know. I mean is there any truth in any of these?

O. Shane Balloun: There may be historical jurisprudential truth in them, depending on how far back you go. The problem with common law, right, is that common law is an amalgamation of, I mean, it used to be hundreds of years ago. That people believed that the common law was the ether. It was something that was preexisting and that judges were trying to draw out from the ether what the common law was.

Timothy Allen: Oh, right. Yes. So what, like a spiritual thing or?

O. Shane Balloun: Kind of, quasi, in a way, sort of like, what are the laws of physics? What is the common law, right? What are the laws of the law?

Timothy Allen: And what was it, like the golden rule or something like that?

O. Shane Balloun: Sort of, but it's like, what is the law that governs our society? We're not determining it, we are discovering it. That was hundreds and hundreds of years ago. I mean, the common law exists from, I mean, essentially the Battle of Hastings onward. And, you know, for a thousand years, we've had development of the common law in England and in all of its colonies. These days, right, the common, and since then over time, the common law was, quote, discovered, and then it shifted from discovery into sort of pronouncement as to what it is. So judges didn't, I mean, they were pronouncing what it was, but they didn't see themselves as doing it. They saw themselves as discovering. Later on, it became, I am dictating to you what the law is. Now, it may be based on an assessment of societal norms, but it became much more prescriptive. and proscriptive. Nowadays, sure, you might be able to track back a certain principle that returns to something from 500 or 600 years ago, or maybe more recently, and assert it. But a lot of that is decayed. It's sort of like there's a radioactive decay of the law, and it's lost. No judge believes that anymore. So convincing a judge who currently has power in jurisdiction over you in his or her courtroom, it's kind of a far stretch unless that person is an independent thinker. And most lawyers are actually not independent thinkers. Some are, but most are essentially engaged in a jurisdictional and jurisprudential box that's fairly limited. And escaping that takes someone who is really very thoughtful and also someone who's willing to be a little bit iconoclastic. And so the idea that you might be discovering some old, you know, pre-constitutional aspect of common law, and then trying to apply it is a really, it's almost a fool's errand. That doesn't mean that I don't believe that the fundamental assertion is morally right? I mean, humans were created by God and we are made in his image and we do have aspects of sovereignty in that. But unfortunately, a lot of the world is satanic and and there's this constant battle between good and evil, right? And you see that play out. I mean, you see people go to jail all the time for things that are literally not immoral and people who walk away free after having done heinous things that are immoral. So, the world is topsy turvy, and I sympathize with it. But just because you think you've discovered something doesn't mean that, you know, that's going to work out the way you hope.

Timothy Allen: Joe mentioned something. I hadn't heard this before, but is it true that a seastead just got a Panama flag somewhere? He mentioned it in his talk. I caught it, and I thought I hadn't heard that before. Because I think Joe, every time I've spoken to Joe recently, it's it's been his life's mission to get seasteads flagged because they, you know, we've been talking about that a long time.

O. Shane Balloun: I don't know how much I'm allowed to say. I know that we have a line on one of the seasteads being flagged in Panama under a certain new classification. And I believe that once that takes hold, that will be a repeatable experience.

Timothy Allen: So I'll ask him. I'm talking to Joe in a couple of days, but I just saw it then, and I thought, how did I not know about that? I thought maybe he announced it here at the conference or something. Maybe that was it.

O. Shane Balloun: I think so. It's candidly, it's very exciting because we've been conceiving of this for quite a long time and things appear to have come together. I don't know that it's fully perfected yet, right? I can't it's not like you can go to the Panama flagging store, and then, you know, buy a seasteading flag just yet. But I I think that we're pretty close.

Timothy Allen: I mean, that's the big that's the final boss of seasteading, isn't it? The flag, right?

O. Shane Balloun: Kind of, right. So, that goes back to my earlier comment about whether the seastead is a vessel or not, right? So, you don't have to flag non-vessels, right? If you have, you know, an oil spar that's dug into the ground or a seamount or something else that has, that isn't, isn't a vessel any longer or isn't, hasn't ever been a vessel, then you don't need a flag. It's just a question of, is that thing on the EEZ or is it not? And if it is, do you have the permission of the host country to be there? And what are the laws surrounding that? But if it's not moving and has no susceptibility to move, then it doesn't necessarily need a flag. But flagging is pretty, it's a safeguard. It's a safeguard. It's a prophylactic safeguard, right? If you get a flag just in case it needs to be motile and or it's towed or it has its own mode of power or every 10 years it needs to move, the idea is that the flag will give the protection of that host country's sovereignty so that the seastead is not subject to the, you know, the simultaneous jurisdiction of 200 nation states. So.

Timothy Allen: Which is a concept I've not heard before. But how does it work? How does it work if it's 200 nations? Does that mean anyone within those, any of those nations can respond? And there was like a universal set of laws?

O. Shane Balloun: No, it's, yeah, sort of. It's the, any nation state can investigate and board. Imagine being harassed at random by any navy or Coast Guard that you come across at any time.

Timothy Allen: But if you have a flag, they can't board?

O. Shane Balloun: They can. So they can if you're in. So let me, let's explain how the jurisdictional, the cross jurisdiction works. If the vessel is just at open sea, there's one nation that has control over it. It's the flagging nation. If the vessel enters the EEZ and isn't doing anything with the resources, there's one nation that has control over it.

Timothy Allen: Define the EEZ quickly.

O. Shane Balloun: Oh, it's 200 miles out from each nation state. Of course, with the subtended borders, sometimes it gets complicated, especially with, you know, like Madagascar, right? Has a problem because it's EEZ isn't quite the same as, you know, South Africa is going to extend beyond Madagascar. And so where does one end and one end begin? But essentially for most nations, it's 200 miles out. If the vessel is in or moving through the EEZ but not engaged in resource extraction, there's one nation that has control over it. That's the flagging nation. Once the vessel moves into the contiguous zone, which is the customs waters or the territorial sea and is moving through without and it's apparent from its course and its conduct that it is it is literally seeking passage through and is not stopping. That the nearby nation is not supposed to engage in investigation without some form of probable cause. I forget what the standard is. It's not probable cause, but it's something like that. And then if, so that's called the rite of an innocent passage. So if, for example, if I'm on my vessel and it's flagged a U.S. flag, and I'm traveling through the English Channel, right? England or great United Kingdom and France are not supposed to bother me if I'm just kind of merrily going along my way. Now, if I've stopped in the waters, or it looks like I'm approaching one of the shores, or engaged in other behavior that, indicates that I'm not just passing through. Then if I'm inside the contiguous zone, the country, the 24 miles, the country may investigate and board what it believes to be potential violations of their customs laws or immigration laws. So that's going to be true. And you should just functionally think if you're on a seastead that's flagged, that you're boardable at any time once you cross 24 miles. Once you cross into the 12 miles, then every nation state where you're inside their territorial waters has the absolute right to stop and board you at any time for document checks for any reason. So the Coast Guard uses that all the time, right? The Coast Guard, there's, And by the way, in the United States, you know, the Fourth Amendment, which, you know, prevents unreasonable searches and seizures. People don't realize there is no Fourth Amendment on the water. It does not exist, right? If you're on a vessel, you are subject to the Coast Guard's jurisdiction at any time for any reason. There's like, you don't get a Fourth Amendment protection there. So, and that's true for all vessels everywhere inside of territorial waters. So it is important, I think, for seasteads to be, if they want to be unbothered, to be beyond the 12 miles in general. But if you're between 12 and 24, you're still going to, you know, suffer from some investigations.

Timothy Allen: Is maritime law, there is only one maritime law throughout the world. Is that right?

O. Shane Balloun: No. No. I mean, there's the law of the sea. Which.

Timothy Allen: That sounds like an old folklore or something.

O. Shane Balloun: Kind of. Yeah. I mean the law of the sea has been around for hundreds of years.

Timothy Allen: Does it have any legal precedence now?

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah. Yeah. Oh yeah. Absolutely.

Timothy Allen: And it's different to sort of well maritime law. What? Jesus. The law of the sea. That sounds like something an old guy with a beard says in a pub. Ah, you broke the laws of the sea. You.

O. Shane Balloun: And you should voice it. That was perfect.

Timothy Allen: Yeah.

O. Shane Balloun: There gosh if you were to.

Timothy Allen: Well I mean what I'm trying to ascertain is whether or not maritime law is actually good law like say for example I look at the U.S. law and your amendments and your, you know the all the, and I think it's pretty good like relatively speaking.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah.

Timothy Allen: It's good. Sure. You know, I [unclear] miss freedom of speech for example in the UK I love the fact that you inscribed in your rules is the fact that you can say things out loud mostly. What's maritime law like? Is it a pretty good set of laws?

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah, I mean, maritime law goes back 3000 plus years.

Timothy Allen: Yeah, that's what I'm talking about.

O. Shane Balloun: The Phoenicians and, I mean, later on in kind of, I guess, Middle Ages, the Rôles of Oléron, and then you have the instantiation of English admiralty courts and, you had, all sorts of different and an amalgam of all sorts of different behavior in the Mediterranean, especially, where seafarers would go from port to port, right? And there was no way necessarily of knowing who the owner of the vessel was and whether the ship would return if there was a claim made against it. And so all of these procedures and rights grew up around the idea that ships are mobile and you have to assume that you're never going to get the owner who might be, you know, on a faraway land. And so we need to have a set of rules that apply in a different way that they would apply on land, which is why ships forever have had their own legal personalities, right? So, you know, how corporations have their own personalities. That actually comes from maritime law. Ships were the proto-corporations. The idea is like, well, we don't know who the shareholders are, the owners are. So, we're going to charge the ship with these liabilities based on the fact that we'll never be able to find the owners. And if we have to, we'll sell the ship and all of its goods to pay for the liabilities caused by collision, allision, breach of contract, maritime liens, et cetera. And that grew up in different ways. And they've all sort of, like I said, amalgamated. And every country, every nation state has its own maritime laws in terms of commercial shipping and commercial enterprise. The law of the sea, what we were talking about, the law of the sea is really a political order around what has personhood, how jurisdiction is exerted. So, we were talking about the law of the sea before without naming it. Maritime law is what do you do with the claims that arise when you're doing commercial seafaring. So yes, there are a bunch of maritime laws. England has, sorry I say England, I should say United Kingdom, but United Kingdom has its own, France has its own, Germany has its own, Turkey has its own, Greece has its own, Libya has its own probably.

Timothy Allen: But the law of the sea is universal.

O. Shane Balloun: The law of the sea is quasi-universal.

Timothy Allen: Yeah. And is the law of the sea good for freedom? Is it, you know?

O. Shane Balloun: That's a good question.

Timothy Allen: Would it be a good set of rules to have?

O. Shane Balloun: Okay. So it's so your questions are so in insightful and they bring up so many jurisprudential answers that I it's like.

Timothy Allen: Just give me the top two.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah. How do I go into international law? So international law is an agreement among nation states. Again, we have the Westphalian order to interact with one another on an equal sovereignty basis. So the United States is supposed to interact with the, you know, Burkina Faso on an equal manner, right? When it comes to international law. Now, in practice with the UN and it being a, you know, a permanent voting member of the Security Council, it's not the way it works, it's the U.S. and, you know, there are two, the largest two air forces in the world are the United States Air Force, the United States Navy. So ultimately the massive amount of power projection of the United States changes that dynamic quite a bit, but theoretically they supposed to interact with one another on an equal basis. And so if, you know the Coast Guard wants to board a Burkinabè ship, it will I mean it's supposed to call the representative, get permission, and then do so. And they typically do that unless the Coast Guard just wants to assert that there's some sort of wrongdoing and they'll board anyway, but they're supposed to. And so international law allows for all of these actors to pretend that they're equals, and then argue with one another or resolve disputes, but they do it in a sovereign manner, right? No one actually has to comply, but they all sort of agree to do it because it's nice to live in a neighborhood wherever all the neighbors get along. That's literally how it works. We're subject to the vertical assertion of power through jurisdiction and criminal law, etc., either by our own nation states or when we cross borders by our host nation states. But nations among one another are supposed to interact like good neighbors. Okay, And that's international law. So then they have these formal things called treaties, right? And treaties are obviously where the nations sign them, but not every nation signs treaties. U.S. is famous for not signing treaties. Or they're famous for having a president or the secretary of state or ambassador sign the treaty and the Senate never ratifying. So does it have the force of law in the United States? No. Does the international community consider it to have the force of law? Kind of. But they know the Senate hasn't ratified it and the Senate never will. For example, there are a number of maritime treaties that the U.S. is never going to be a party to. But the U.S. treats the the most parts of the treaties as if they were good law with respect to U.S. enforcement, but they reserve the right for particular aspects because they don't want to be bound by a couple of items in the treaty. And so then we get to what is called opinio juris. So like opinion, but opinio, and then juris, J-U-R-I-S. And that's the idea that something is, back to the common law, sort of an understood, quote unquote, common law of international law. And so the U.S. will observe opinio juris as if it were part of a concluded treaty that the U.S. has signed, but it actually hasn't signed, but it's still treated as good law. So you've got all these different layers of, okay, we have the law of the sea, or we have the opinio juris, and then we have these treaties, which your country may or may not be a part of, but everyone mostly does them. But hey, we reserve the right not to. So when you said, is there one maritime law? No, there's, again, an amalgam, a total mixture, an admixture of various different laws that apply. So then you say, well, is the law of the sea good? Is it good for freedom? I don't know. It presumes that, well, it presumes the background framework of the Westphalian nation state. So is that good for freedom? Not necessarily, But it does appear to be workable. I mean, you can get on a cruise ship, right? And know that because of the international frameworks, and even if you have, let's say a cruise ship is flagged in Panama or Bermuda or somewhere that has no means of exerting power, good or bad. I mean, Bermuda is not going to, it's not going to do anything, right? Not for real. But, you know, you can trust, you get on the cruise ship, right? And your life isn't really in jeopardy. The captain isn't going to take you hostage or put you in jail or leave you out floating in the ocean, right? You know, you're pretty safe. Why is that? Well, because we have this long history of common law, opinio juris, these subtle sort of agreements that we have as a society to make it work, and it kind of does. So, anyway, that's maybe too long of an answer.

Timothy Allen: No, not at all. I'm just trying to get a sense of it, because I think of the sea as the last frontier, and I think seasteads are a great idea, and I think if you believe in liberty, there's no better vehicle to obtain liberty currently. If you if you stack them all up, I think than a floating place that can move around when it doesn't like you anymore, it's like, oh, let's just go over there then and they'll leave us alone. But I was wondering, you know, if the I've never I've never even thought what that's law of the sea might be. I know that by having a flag, you can basically, for all intents and purposes, enter enemy territory without them doing anything. Like, you know, a cruise ship sails into America with a Panama flag, no one's going, Oh my God, who are these guys? They're right. Sure. They're just like, Oh, it's just it's us guys. We're cool. Even though the ship's probably from Norway, the crew are from Brazil. The Philippines. Always from.

O. Shane Balloun: The Philippines.

Timothy Allen: All right. I've never been on one actually.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah.

Timothy Allen: But it's which is why I find the whole thing amazing and excellent. But it strikes me that most people when they look at it, and that's me to start with was looking at it going, Hold on a minute, that's quite an easy system to sort of scam and to do, you know, which is kind of what's happening with seasteading. The only reason it exists is because laws and the land are bad and there's authoritarians there who want to tell you what to do. So all the seasteaders are doing is trying to just skirt the rules and try and do it over here. And presumably the rules will catch up with them there in the end. I don't know. You know, I would imagine it would. I mean, I think the whole process of finding frontiers that are free, and then inhabiting them, and then having everyone come in, and then basically telling you what to do. This is a very uniquely human thing that happens all the time. Happens everywhere. Even in other modes of life like the internet used to be a frontier and now it's much more gate kept and there's many more things you have to do and the sea presumably one day if they can do it'll be policed as well in the same way it may be out of space eventually I don't know how they'll do that, but I mean that's the ultimate right floating around space on a Death Star or a nice Death Star not the death Star but that's the ultimate right.

O. Shane Balloun: Well I mean even in Star Wars right you're the floating city Bespin where Lando Calrissian is the administrator and guess who shows up to put a wrinkle in all their plans right it's Darth Vader.

Timothy Allen: So what and he with the Death Star.

O. Shane Balloun: Well he shows up on his on his on his Imperial Star Destroyer but he comes in right and he was trying to capture Luke and Han and, you know it's supposed to be an independently administered yeah functional city but the Empire comes and does what it wants.

Timothy Allen: Yeah, And that's the eternal battle between good and evil, as you put it.

O. Shane Balloun: Right.

Timothy Allen: That's never going away. But I do like the way that you can, you know, you can work the rules in your favor by going to certain places. I mean, this is what Próspera is. It's a jurisdictional arbitrage.

O. Shane Balloun: That's right. As I recall, the only part of Honduran law that really applies in Próspera is the criminal law. But other than that, right, people are free to choose.

Timothy Allen: As far as I know, Yeah.

O. Shane Balloun: But I'm not an expert.

Timothy Allen: No, me neither. I tend to think of it as more like legislative. No, more like what's my Not legislation. Oh my God, I've just lost the word I was trying to think of. Regulatory law, if you see what I mean. Like I mean that's what most people go on about here that it's about the regulations imposed on the doing of things, if you see what I mean.

O. Shane Balloun: But I don't think most good people really want to be free from the most fundamental prescriptions of society. right? No one is thinking I want to I want to be in a place where killing for hire is okay. right? That's not that's not fundamentally that's not fundamentally good human behavior it's it's it's I mean totally immoral Right So that not the type of jurisdiction that people I think want to escape. What they're looking to escape is two things, I think. One is the application of whatever law exists for political purposes, right? So maybe we have a good law, maybe we have a bad law, but there's selective enforcement based on whoever's in power and whatever they want to achieve and accomplish. And I think that there's a cry for human freedom that always wants to get away from that. And then the second thing is whether, so that's procedural or political, right? Is the law, whether the law is good or bad, how is it enforced? I mean, if it's enforced consistently, even if it's a bad law, at least you're like, well, they're doing it consistently. What's worse is when it's like, I'll only do it to my enemies and selectively. And then the second thing is I want to get away from bad law. And people have disagreements about what bad law is. And there's a contingent of world society, right, in every country, every tribe, where people want, there are certain people who want to get away and there are certain people who want to claw them back.

Timothy Allen: Right. And it's these people.

O. Shane Balloun: Right. These are the Free Cities, people.

Timothy Allen: These are the seasteaders. These are the. Don't tread on me.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah. The don't tread on me. You know, the American Revolutionaries, the Pilgrims, the people who came over across to the new world. Look, you can have your society. We're leaving it behind. We're going to go do something else.

Timothy Allen: There's always this the grasp to try to, you know, it's not even to bring you back. It's to take over what you've done. That's the more that's the worst thing about it because what you're doing is better than there.

O. Shane Balloun: Actually. That's basically it. It is Envy. It is.

Timothy Allen: It's socialist envy. I was thinking about the regulations what we were just talking about there and law, etc., and what makes a place like Próspera better or worse But regulation is an interesting one because people, you know, there's a lot of entrepreneurs here. And the bane of their lives is bad regulations or too many regulations.

O. Shane Balloun: That's right.

Timothy Allen: Correct me if I'm wrong, but in maritime law, regulations aren't something that are universally enforced. They're more like a function of the individuals, like take a massive ship full of people on holiday. The rules that they assert, the way they build the ship, the way it's all done, are not necessarily regulations imposed on them. More like the regulations evolve out of the fact that they don't want to kill anyone or they don't really want anyone to get hurt and stuff like that. Is it different? Am I getting that right? There's something slightly different about the way regulations get kind of like on land. Regulations come into effect on the whole. Someone sits down and says, yeah, we need to regulate that. I don't know. I heard it from someone and never really got to the bottom of it.

O. Shane Balloun: That's interesting. I mean, I think there are, again, I think there are.

Timothy Allen: Sorry. It's like they make their own regulations. Like cruise ships, the regulators are like private companies rather than the government. Do you see what I mean?

O. Shane Balloun: So I think what you're getting at is there may be a minimum set of regulations in the flagging registry or in the flagging host country. And they are minimum for a reason, right? They are minimum so that those countries can attract flagging business so that companies will flag their ships in those places. And yet those companies, if they're reputable, are willing to increase the number of self-regulatory activities because they're also incentivized not to allow their customers to get hurt or die. And so, yes, so it's a counterpoint to the idea that, oh, if a ship is being flagged in a small country, that it's going to create a parade of horribles in terms of anti-regulatory effect. But it's not true. And I think that's probably what that person meant.

Timothy Allen: But also, you said it there, this is what it was. It's The fact that the flagging industry is a competitive industry.

O. Shane Balloun: Between countries.

Timothy Allen: It's brilliant.

O. Shane Balloun: Yes.

Timothy Allen: Because that's kind of what we want between nation states. But more often than not, apart from a few, something like Dubai, say, the Emirates, who really are trying to compete for you. They're trying to woo you in because it's, you know, most, well, I don't know whether most is right. But a lot, my own included, of nation states aren't really trying to compete for you anymore. It's the opposite. They've got you. If anything, they're trying to stop you leaving. Whereas with flagging in its nature, it's like competitive between countries, which is like I was saying, is it a good system? It seems like a good system. It seems like the foundations of flagging, maritime law, sea law, lend themselves to a good society. If I may be so bold.

O. Shane Balloun: It's fundamentally British and fundamentally American.

Timothy Allen: I take full responsibility.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah, I bet you should. And I mean, you wouldn't have that type of let's put the rule of law as a superstructure upon the activities of the sea, right, without Britain having done it to begin with. It has all of the indicia of British rule of law. And, so I agree with you. I think it's a brilliant system. And it's why, you know, Panama is the largest registry in the world. And the Marshall Islands and Liberia aren't far behind.

Timothy Allen: Liberia?

O. Shane Balloun: Oh, Liberia is a huge registry.

Timothy Allen: I thought Liberia had a pirate problem. Jesus, obviously not.

O. Shane Balloun: No, Liberia.

Timothy Allen: Somalia and places like that.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah, No, Liberia, I mean, it's more on the commercial side, but I mean, the number of vessels that are registered at the same registration broker at 20 Broad Street, Monrovia in Liberia is enormous. They all have the same It's like when you go and see a list of companies registered in Delaware or Wyoming and they all have the same address. It's the same idea.

Timothy Allen: I've worked in Liberia, mate. I wouldn't have said it was somewhere I would trust especially Monrovia, right? It was rife with corruption. Basically, I worked with NGOs there and the money was being funneled all over the place and hardly any of it was going anywhere. We went to check it out it was like well probably.

O. Shane Balloun: Not anymore. Probably since the disbanding of USAID, it's not quite as, Who knows?

Timothy Allen: I mean, no, these were British. These were British NGOs. But the point was, as a place.

O. Shane Balloun: Oh, that didn't matter. We funded everybody.

Timothy Allen: Is that right?

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah, no. If you look at the records, the US funded a lot of things.

Timothy Allen: But anyway, so the conclusion we've got then is, or the conclusion I've got is, seasteading and maritime law and the law of the sea are a great combination of freedom and it really is at the best I think it's the best bet on this amount of freedom. Sure, if you want to live in a nation state and do your thing that's cool. But if you're a real liberty loving freedom lover, there's only one place to live and that is out at sea. I think on the scale I mean of it. I mean on the scale of liberty, there's no better place.

O. Shane Balloun: On the scale of liberty. I think you're right. Right. We're not there in space yet. I mean, so I saw something on Twitter and or X that I wish I had thought of, but it's absolutely true is that 10,000 years hence, right, when people look back at the history of humanity and they will realize that 99% or 90 some percent of the history of humanity has been spacefaring, right? At some point, like you said, the sea will have become an inevitable place for population. We're not there yet, but I think you're right. It is inevitable. The question is on what timeline and with what technology jumps. And of course, that will invite more in different types of governance. But for the current, right, it does present on the axis of liberty a very high means of obtaining that liberty. I do think, and this [false start], that's applicable to anyone in the world, right? I think that the only other comparison for that level of access to liberty is probably if you happen to have been born in the United States, and you have the means of moving around to different states, which still compete with one another. Although I know this isn't quite the focus of the topic of our podcast today, but, you know, we've had 50 states for a long time and a lot of them have similar legislation based on congressional pressures, right? Congress can't make states do anything. People don't realize that states are totally sovereign, totally quote unquote, totally sovereign, but Congress can't make them pass, but they can incentivize them with money. So they steal money from the citizens, and then use that money to incentivize states to regulate. And some states often will, but they don't always and they don't always do it the same way and they may disagree. And so it's like, you know what? If I don't like the way that California is treating me, I'm going to move to Texas or somewhere else because that allows me that competition between these governing bodies. And that's kind of what you were talking about with governing, you know, flagging registries. Unfortunately, you know, not everybody is born into that. And so for most people, right, I mean, if you're born into one country that's pretty top down, what are you going to do? right? How do you how do you get out of that? How do you say, I don't want to live here anymore, and I'm stuck with my citizenship because we're all treated in a way like cattle. How can I how can I improve my own freedom? right? And I think seasteading in the as it progresses offers that level of freedom for people.

Timothy Allen: You think there'll be that much of a low bar of entry, a low level of, you know low cost of entry eventually?

O. Shane Balloun: Sure. I mean, that's the thoroughfare, the pathway of economics over time. Sure. Eventually.

Timothy Allen: Would you live on a seastead? A big one like a big floating city.

O. Shane Balloun: I might consider it, but it would have to be fairly advanced for me to really like.

Timothy Allen: What's your minimum requirement on a...?

O. Shane Balloun: Oh, gosh, that's a piercing question.

Timothy Allen: When I think about it, I don't think of metal structures clamped together and all this kind of stuff. I think that there's going to be beaches. They're going to look like islands. They're going to, you know, technology is going to solve every single problem. And I suspect that in the future seasteads will be places you turn up. It's like arriving at a tropical island or arriving at a forested island or whatever.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah. Sort of like an artificial Maldives right?

Timothy Allen: Yeah.

O. Shane Balloun: Sure. I mean, that would be amazing.

Timothy Allen: Why not? Yeah.

O. Shane Balloun: I'm not particularly personally inclined to live on something that looks like, you know, a Waterworld container ships together, but.

Timothy Allen: Or Sealand.

O. Shane Balloun: Not quite. Yeah. Although I really respect the ability of people to do it.

Timothy Allen: Sealand. Awesome. I've interviewed Liam who's the grandson.

O. Shane Balloun: That's right.

Timothy Allen: And actually, I'm doing a talk tomorrow, and I'm going to mention Sealand because there's so many funny stories from that era. They were cut from a different cloth. Those people they literally just went somewhere, took control of it, and when the British Navy turned up, they fired shots at them and said, Fuck off. This is ours. No. Can you imagine? People doing that.

O. Shane Balloun: I know. And because Britain, you know what? God bless the British, right at that time to say, We don't like it, but what is the law? We're not sure what the law is. We're gonna leave and come back. We're gonna think about it. The Americans would have just taken it over. They would have just destroyed it.

Timothy Allen: Like you said earlier, that's a kind of modern phenomenon. People are far less respectful of even like what we call them gentlemen's, you know, like the law of thieves and gentlemen's law and, you know that kind of unwritten rule.

O. Shane Balloun: That's all British.

Timothy Allen: Yeah. But I wish that came back. I think it's never going to come back. I think possibly it could come back in places in small jurisdictions actually. You could easily see it arising again, and I would move to a place where there was that kind of respect for the law, you know.

O. Shane Balloun: Sure but unfortunately yeah we've gone in the last say 50 years probably or maybe since the 60s.

Timothy Allen: It started. It's degrading.

O. Shane Balloun: It's post-war.

Timothy Allen: You think so?

O. Shane Balloun: It's post-World War II yep.

Timothy Allen: And what, you think that had an effect on just the psyche of people that they stopped trusting I mean because it has gone hand in hand with people also being very people in power being very bad and not respecting you as an individual and all that. It's not and that's not going to affect now is that in many countries you can just walk into a shop and nick stuff and no one's going to do anything.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah, that's.

Timothy Allen: And that's a different issue, but it's it.

O. Shane Balloun: I see what you're saying. I think post-war, the post-war order, meaning obviously World War II, there has been an exponential increase of the assertion of law being used as an assertion of power rather than a set of fair rules. And you see that in a number of places. But essentially law the the goodness of law has collapsed.

Timothy Allen: You're right. That's a real shame, isn't it? A real shame. Well, it is. It'll always be a shame, but there is possibly a movement towards back towards that direction because it has other elements to it. Traditionalism in general, you know, and even I don't know building vernaculars and anything that you would call kind of like traditional. There is a movement of people going hold a minute this isn't really what we want. We were all like yeah live and let live anyone can do whatever they want. It's certainly this is the kind of feeling I have in my country anyway. It's like we are like we we British people like you say polite oh, you know you can do your thing just, you know and we will never complain, and then before, you know it now you're like hold a minute what no one's doing it. What happened to my society?

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah. And I'll say it but yes.

Timothy Allen: True. But it's not even, it's not, I don't think it has, I'm not going to blame even immigration. I'm not going to blame this. Because it's also people that, it's people who've been living in the country for generations also doing that shit. It's almost like when it breaks down at that level, if you join, if you do it the old fashioned way, you're an idiot because you lose. Unless you've managed to do it in a small enclave where everyone does it. You basically get the piss taken out of you, as you would say in the UK. It doesn't work. It needs a border around it. That kind of lawfulness and moral stance, It needs a wall around it. It doesn't work when everyone doesn't adhere to it.

O. Shane Balloun: Well, what you've just described is a nation.

Timothy Allen: True.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah, But it's not a nation based on arbitrary drawing of lines. It's a nation based on the fundamental properties of the society, of the people in society saying, this is the way that we act. And we also have a wall around us and we're not going to let you in because you haven't proven to us that you're going to act in the same way. Just because you were you were colonists of ours 100 200 years ago doesn't mean necessarily that you share the same ways of thinking about society. Your ways of thinking may be so antithetical or so orthogonal to ours that it would be a mistake for you for us to allow you to gain any significant percentage of our population because it will alter the dynamics of how we interact with one another. And that is I mean I will say that is what has happened to Great Britain. That's what happened to the United Kingdom. And what you're describing is literally re-enclaving based on that phenomenon. And it's happening in the United States and, you know, if we bring it back to seasteading, at least you could theoretically float away from the, if your HOA, right, became difficult and they started charging you for not painting, you know, your seastead panels green in the right color because they didn't match, you know, their authoritative list of Pantones. Their schedule of Pantones you're like, you know what I really like this mauve better than this than this green this Kelly Green well we're gonna fine you for that well, you know what I'm leaving right you can do that theoretically in a sea stead you can't do that on land. To your point, on land you have to exclude denaturalize deport conquer like those are your choices on land. On sea, maybe you can just sail away.

Timothy Allen: I think possibly that's what the whole freedom movement is currently. It's a re-enclaving, almost. I mean, it is that. A few years ago we would talk about two strategies one is stay and fight and the other is flee to the frontier, and I don't really hear stay and fight as much anymore. Certainly, I mean I'm not in the states as much as you obviously, but in my country I hear that far less. I don't notice people shoulder to shoulder saying like, you know it's more like where are we gonna Where are we gonna go? Where we're treated well. That's that's in my in my little bit, yeah.

O. Shane Balloun: That's because your government has betrayed you.

Timothy Allen: Oh, fully.

O. Shane Balloun: Oh, it's more [unclear].

Timothy Allen: More than that. They're just I think I don't even blame people. The people are just responding to incentives.

O. Shane Balloun: Exactly. Right.

Timothy Allen: I blame the fact that it's just transpired that way and there's nothing I can do about it. And there's I know that it's too big. It's bigger than me. It's gonna it's gonna continue happening. The only choices I have is how I respond to it.

O. Shane Balloun: And that is the frontier mindset.

Timothy Allen: Funnily enough. It is really, you know, and I think, you know, probably I you know, I'd have been on a ship to the States if I had been born 200 years ago or whatever.

O. Shane Balloun: Oh, I'm sure you would have.

Timothy Allen: Yeah. Yeah. I wish one of my ancestors had actually. I love [unclear]. Whereabouts do you live in the States?

O. Shane Balloun: I split time between Washington State and Oregon.

Timothy Allen: Right. Oh, Oregon. Yeah, that's probably the kind of place I'd end up. There's a lot of outdoors stuff in Oregon, isn't there?

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah. Yeah.

Timothy Allen: And I mean, there is in everywhere really.

O. Shane Balloun: No, I mean, we have, it's funny. Did you see maybe on Twitter or I keep calling Twitter X all the Europeans had come over for the World Cup and they were just marveling at a number of things, right? Marveled at the topography, right? We just have a lot of different topography. It's pretty majestic. And then of course we had free bathrooms, free water, air conditioning.

Timothy Allen: Large portions. Yeah.

O. Shane Balloun: Large portions.

Timothy Allen: They just didn't check the tax code.

O. Shane Balloun: That's the tax code is overly complex. It's.

Timothy Allen: No, but I mean you're the one thing I find astonishing about America is if you leave America and you don't denounce your citizenship. You pay tax wherever you are. It's crazy. That is, and I know that they can do that because they're America and everyone wants to live there. But still, come on, It's the land of the free, man.

O. Shane Balloun: I know.

Timothy Allen: Let people go.

O. Shane Balloun: It's totally hypocritical. If people want to leave, they should be able to leave.

Timothy Allen: Without having to renounce your citizenship. Just to give some context to that thing about the World Cup. It's true that we are given the impression that America, I had this myself. I mean, I went through that process that the World Cup people went through quite a long time ago. Sure. But I went I went through it nevertheless. I realized like, you know, we the meme is no culture in America. Crass, you know, when you get there, you realize there's culture everywhere. It's just American culture. It's like and it's diverse and it's so cool and, but I think a lot of it comes down to the fact that we're quite socialist in the UK and we're quite lefty. And the American dream is libertarian. It's not the same thing. And as a result, a lot of people sneer at it, you know, because it's like, no, individualism is like, you know, you can do what it is. It's kind of like the collectivists don't like individuals succeeding. And it's just without realizing it just pervades under the surface. I, you know, and really we should have grown up idolizing the place. And I wasn't offered the opportunity to do that until I went there. And fortunately now my kids, my oldest is 14, she's obsessed with cowboys, cowgirls. She rides horses in the UK, but she does it, she trains them western style, and she follows really.

O. Shane Balloun: Not English style.

Timothy Allen: Natural horsemanship, it's called. And, you know, we've been there. We went to Nashville. I spent six weeks living in Nashville with the kids. And they love it. They can't wait to get back out there. And it's not just because everything's big and beautiful and stuff like that. It's just the mentality. It's the fact that when you say, Can you do that, someone says, Yes.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah.

Timothy Allen: And in the UK, that's a no or a maybe these days. It's a really weird place. It's a really kind of scarcity in the UK and you can feel it. Everyone's getting a bit jittery. You can't do anything unless you're allowed.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah.

Timothy Allen: Yeah.

O. Shane Balloun: Absolutely.

Timothy Allen: It's this weird hinterland between continental Europe where that's really the case always. You know, you are not allowed.

O. Shane Balloun: I mean, the difference between the fundamental difference between the English Common Law and the Roman Civil Law at bottom is under the Roman Civil Law, you can't do anything unless you're allowed. And under the English Common Law, you can do anything unless it's prohibited. And that's why in the states in the U.S. where you have a lot of civil code type regulations, I mean, Louisiana, California has a huge civil code. Washington has a, you know the Revised Code of Washington, etc. Those are, they look a little bit more like unless we've allowed you to do it you're prohibited. It's not quite that way, but it's annoying and Britain is in the middle, right? It's like, it used to be, you can do whatever you want unless it's prohibited. But over time, because I think because of the European Union and pre-Brexit, et cetera, it just, it just kind of got ossified into, we're not allowed to do anything unless the government says we can do it. Or, you know, you're not supposed to do it. And so even though there's no law, the presumption is now, you know, oh, you said a bad thing. There's no law saying that I can't say that thing or no justifiable law, but still you're subject to investigation and arrest just because it's impolite.

Timothy Allen: I interviewed a few weeks a few months ago, I interviewed Lucy Connolly. She's a lady. She did 13 months in prison for a tweet for one tweet. Yeah. But she deleted three hours later because she it was a bit I mean it was it was a it was an immigration thing that an immigrant had done. I forget what it was, killed someone and she said, I can burn them all for all I care. It was a one of those in the moment, angry, whatever. And she actually did. She went out and walked the dog. When she came back.

O. Shane Balloun: Sure Yeah.

Timothy Allen: That was a bit unkind. Sure. Deleted it. Five days later, someone complained. Police came around. Another week later, she was in prison. She did over a year in prison for it. I mean, she was a she wasn't she was a housewife basically. She had no obviously no record of anything. You know, it's really bizarre. I mean, it's it's it's I think I can see it, but a lot of people I'm I know at home aren't acknowledging that thousands and thousands of people are getting are getting questioned by the Gestapo for writing things on the internet.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah. It's what it's what is called and maybe the same in English law, I don't know, but in American jurisprudence is it's called a chilling effect, right? So those laws are designed to have a chilling effect both on speech and on complaining about the laws themselves, right? They're totally immoral. They're totally evil. And I can say that as an American because we've enshrined the First Amendment.

Timothy Allen: Well, that's the thing, you see. And the Constitution is an amazing piece of technology because it's an abstract force that you can call on at any moment. And It was, you know, I was talking to yesterday, Jeremy Kauffman, you know, like, right, he was in it.

O. Shane Balloun: I know Jeremy.

Timothy Allen: Right. Jeremy's like, whenever he needs to call on the Constitution, he kind of summons it in the ether and just stands there and says, No. You know, I'd love to have that. I'd love to have that. I fully am jealous of a nation of people who have access to this abstract power whenever they want. Because in my country, I feel like I have that power. I feel like it, but it carries no weight. And that's no good when the person who's up against you doesn't acknowledge that power as well. And in the States, more often than not, people are I mean, there are stupid people who don't know what it what the law is. But on the whole, everyone's there with the understanding that there are things you can and can't do. And the things you can do are enshrined in a in a document that everyone I mean, not everyone, but most people want.

O. Shane Balloun: Well, we go back to, again, the laws and assertion of power. And then I said the law is not a spell book. But I think the Constitution is the exception to that. And it's the one, quote unquote, spell book that people, that the word is literally used every day somewhere in the United States in some jurisprudence. And very often by the Supreme Court in almost, not every case, but almost, I mean, a majority of cases. The Supreme Court doesn't even take cases unless it has a question of national importance, which often implies the Constitution. Not always, but often does. So, we are routinely calling back to that document, which is why it continues to have power, because everyone is in implied agreement that it does have power and it does have meaning. And so therefore, we can call back to it, unlike these other principles that may have decayed or expired that should be, maybe they should exist, but they don't anymore, and I'm glad that we have it too which is why there's always such a war by people to control what it means, right? No one is in full agreement as to the meaning of the Constitution. There's always so much money and ink spilled over its meaning because it gets to be this spellbinding thing.

Timothy Allen: Well, it also empowers individuals. And people don't, and collectives don't like that. States don't like that.

O. Shane Balloun: Collectives don't like it. And in fact, people forget the Constitution doesn't grant any rights whatsoever to people. None. It only reserves them. It presumes that all these rights are pre-existing. The Constitution presumes a function of natural law, right? The right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. It doesn't say we here, we the people grant the right to ourselves to keep and bear arms. It's no, The right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed. Well, where does that right come from? It comes from God. Why? It comes from your natural right to engage in self-defense, either personally or collectively. The right to say what the hell you want. Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech and of the press and of da da Why is that? Because the right pre-exists. I forget exactly how the Third Amendment is worded, but you don't have to quarter soldiers in your home. The Fourth Amendment, right, your right to the privacy of your papers. These are all things that you have a fundamental that the framers presumed that you had a fundamental natural right to. And actually I mean there was a lot of argument at the Constitutional Convention because the Federalists were saying we need to have a new form of government. The Articles of Confederation were already in place, and so there was a valid lawful government and the framers came together. I mean essentially illegally, right? There was already a government. But they can gather. And so they did. And they worked out this document. And the Anti-Federalists came along and they said, okay, well, you're not guaranteeing all these fundamental natural rights. And they're like, yeah, we know, but we'll get to that later. And then that's where the Bill of Rights came from. It's because the Anti-Federalists who weren't really at the convention were criticizing the Constitutional Convention for this major oversight and Madison and Jay and Hamilton, and I have a lot of qualms with Hamilton who was always very self-interested in self-dealing, they said, okay, well we'll get to it afterward but we just need to get this foundational document in place now. And so then they did, and then fundamentally Madison made good, authored 12 amendments. Two were not ratified. But the 10 that remained were. And I think what is key to remember about them is that they never created rights. Everyone knew at the time that all of those rights came from God, from nature, and that they were they were self-evident. And that's one of the things I like about the Constitution is it doesn't say we hereby pronounce to deign to give you rights. No, it's like these already exist and we're limiting the government, not the other way.

Timothy Allen: A lot of people in America acknowledge that even subconsciously.

O. Shane Balloun: No I think well it depends on where you're raised and and a lot and a lot of places, you know, that would be considered middle America, flyover country, redneck, you know, where rednecks live, or, I mean, essentially wherever you have the band of, there was, I think there's a historical survey that determined that there were functionally like four to five or six different, subpopulations. I think it was four from England that populated America. And one of them was the Scotch-Irish, which ended up being the most willing to fight, the most irascible, most difficult, most freedom-loving people. And it's in those same places in the Midwest where it's on the camera, It's going to be backwards. I guess I should do this. And then here's the Midwest in the Pacific. But in this area where in the south where people fundamentally know that they can do whatever they want. They're like, Hey, this is America. I can do what I want. And it's not quite the right formulation, but what they mean is so long as I'm not harming anybody, I haven't harmed anybody's property or person, I literally can do what I want. That's America.

Timothy Allen: Yes, that is America. I can do what I want. It's a beautiful thing.

O. Shane Balloun: It is a beautiful thing. But if you have all the elites in the cities and all the people who have grown up in more controlled environments, either they're in suburbs or cities their whole lives, they bristle at that because they think, all that's stupid.

Timothy Allen: The truth of the matter is because I live in a remote farm and when I am in a field on my own, nothing is nothing is affecting me apart from the laws of physics.

O. Shane Balloun: That's right.

Timothy Allen: There's no such thing as a [false start], there's no such thing as a given right to me.

O. Shane Balloun: That's right.

Timothy Allen: There, it doesn't exist because I'm not thinking about it. It only exists when I get on my computer, and I have to fill a form in for the government. But other than that, it's a I've never heard anyone describe it like actually. The Constitution mentioning quite specifically that rights aren't given. They're just in existence. These are these are the rights that you're born with.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah. It's even implied by the Constitution. It's not stated. It's just that's the jurisprudence of the political theory of the day and it's the right to shall not be infringed. Well, you're presuming it. The Constitution presumes it.

Timothy Allen: Which is a phenomenal thing when you think about it. That means everyone who all the all the people who are over in America, you know, looking for the free world, that's what they were thinking. That They weren't they that's you can tell that's just they were no one was even contemplating anything else. It was just part of the makeup of a person that lived. And I think I think I'm like that myself. Like I say, when I'm when I'm a when I'm when I'm not interacting with bullshit That's who I am. That There are things that, you know, like there's no such thing as a rule to do this unless I unless I decide myself.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah. No. Yeah. If you're out in your field.

Timothy Allen: Yeah. It's all abstraction anyway.

O. Shane Balloun: Yeah It's abstraction that people buy into. Because if they don't, right, they know that there's someone out there who may decide to use their massive power to enforce their will.

Timothy Allen: No, but that is, I think, if I'm, you know, I'm not a lawyer, so, but I think if I was to construct something legal, it would be that because that's the obvious use of a big abstract power. The individual is sacred for me, but there are times when the individual is not enough. And at those times, it's good to be able to call upon something big that isn't your enemy.

O. Shane Balloun: right? I mean, you know, all of my pure anarcho-capitalist friends will, you know, be annoyed or deride me for this, but there are purposes of government, and the purpose of government is collective defense. right? It's collective defense, and I think ultimately to punish or exile for the most fundamental laws of human nature. And I mean do not murder, do not kidnap, steal, do not steal. It's funny, you know, the Ten Commandments, the original the original command for do not steal is [unclear Hebrew phrase] and it doesn't mean do not steal. It means do not kidnap, right? So, fundamentally the Ten Commandments were against chattel slavery, just FYI.

Timothy Allen: But that might be because there weren't as many possessions.

O. Shane Balloun: Well, it's because human beings were considered to be sacred, right? So, you don't get to just steal another child because you want it or whatever. So my point is that the truest legitimate purpose of government is collective defense and punishment of fundamental wrongdoing. Other than that it's all just assertion of power.

Timothy Allen: O. Shane, it's been lovely talking to you. I'm a little bit wiser, actually.

O. Shane Balloun: Oh, you're very kind.

Timothy Allen: No, I am. That's cleared a couple of things up for me, and I will go forth into the world, and I'll be more effective, and so thanks for that. And I've really enjoyed talking to you.

O. Shane Balloun: I've really enjoyed talking to you as well. We hadn't met before and you're just such a kind host, and I would love to talk to you again [unclear].

Timothy Allen: British, mate. That's what it is. It is what it is.

O. Shane Balloun: Thank you.

Explore more conversations about how places govern themselves on the Free Cities Podcast with Timothy Allen at freecities.fm.

Watch more conversations on Timothy Allen’s YouTube channel.

Related conversations